12 Restaurants in Flagstaff Downtown

November 3, 2023
Food & Drink
jason wolfe
This is some text inside of a div block.

Good day, good morning, or perhaps good evening? I have no idea what time of day you might have stumbled upon this article. But regardless of the time of day, I want to say thank you for the click! I know you are here because you are looking for something great to eat in downtown Flagstaff, Arizona. Well today you are in luck, because I have just the list for you. I’ll feature twelve restaurants that are some of the best you can find in downtown Flagstaff. I’ll give you their addresses, and will even link you to their website. That way, you can check out what they offer on their menus, as well as how much they charge for it. Besides all of that, I will also help you out with a link anytime one of these great restaurants in downtown Flagstaff accept our super convenient digital GiftYa gift cards. 

Virtual GiftYa Cards make the perfect gift for loved ones and for anybody who likes to explore the Flagstaff area or travel. These virtual gift cards can be sent and received within seconds. Usually with a special message inside with well wishes towards a loved one or special friend. 

The virtual gift cards are as easy to send as an email or a text message and can be purchased for nearly ten thousand different merchants and businesses. You can personalize the gift message, and send it directly to your recipient’s phone, all within seconds. GiftYa’s digital format provides not only a speedy delivery but also a convenient way to store and maintain different gift card balances. You don’t need to worry about having that particular gift card for that particular establishment on that particular day, as long as you have your phone, GiftYa cards are with you. Check out our list of top restaurants in downtown Flagstaff, Arizona below, including a few that accept GiftYa!  

1. Fat Olives

Wood Fired Pizzeria and Italian Kitchen in Downtown Flagstaff

2308 E Rt 66 | Downtown | fatolivesflagstaff.com

If you are looking for amazing food in downtown Flagstaff, Arizona, then look no farther than Fat Olives. Fat Olives features a menu of fantastic pizza and Italian Cuisine, which I think makes it perfect for lunch or dinner. But more than anything, Fat Olives is at the top of the list today because they have an overwhelmingly positive amount of feedback from their customer base. When a company has hundreds and hundreds of reviews and manages to boast a four and a half star rating, you know they are delivering fantastic food and service time after time. 

“Second time visiting this restaurant and it was as good as the first visit!! A birthday celebration was amazing here, and I definitely recommend calling in advance to make a reservation rather than a spur of the moment drop in. This place is always booked and busy, and it's worth the call ahead.” - Yelp Review 

2. Lumberyard Tap Room & Grille

Best Place To Grab Grub and a Drink In Downtown Flagstaff

5 S San Francisco Street | Downtown | lumberyardbrewingcompany.com

Lumberyard Tap Room & Grille serves a cuisine that you might consider traditional American cuisine, or maybe even barbeque. But mostly you can expect great brewery style food served up with some craft beers and excellent drinks. If you are looking for a place to grab a drink with your meal then Lumberyard Tap Room & Grille is by far going to be the spot for you. And to be honest, I had a really hard time pinning down just what exactly to call their menu offerings. So I would recommend you follow the link up there and check out their menu offerings before they go. It all seems delicious to me, but it’s impossible to try everything on a menu.

“This place is so good! My husband and I stopped here on a Sunday afternoon for lunch. I love that they have vegan cheese and gluten free options. The burgers are amazing! This is a great place to stop in for lunch or beers.” - Yelp Review

3. Tinderbox Kitchen

Best Place In Downtown Flagstaff for Dinner

34 S San Francisco Street | Downtown | tinderboxkitchen.com

Tinderbox Kitchen is going to be the place for you if you are looking for a great dinner spot in downtown Flagstaff. They have a highly crafted menu they serve up in a freshly renovated dining room. They feature everything from Duck Confit to Filet Mignon for dinner so feel free to take a look through their full offerings to see if they have your personal favorite dish or dinner. And on top of the extensively prepared dinner menu, there is an equally well prepared wine menu so they can offer you the perfect pairing no matter what you order. 

“Must Try!!! One of the best dining experiences from the excellent service to our fantastic meal! Everything was so delicious! We sat at the bar and Sage was great explaining the menu and made the best drinks!” - Yelp Review 

4. Beaver Street Brewery & Whistle Stop Cafe

Most Balanced Menu Offering In Downtown Flagstaff

11 S Beaver Street | Downtown | beaverstreetbrewery.com

The great thing about Beaver Street Brewery & Whistle Stop Cafe is that they have something on their menu for everybody. Everything from sandwiches, salads, soups, and pizza are on the menu there. And it can all be served up with handcrafted ales and lagers brewed right on the premises. Although you might think of their menu as being a pub menu, this is no simple pub. They serve everything made up of the finest quality ingredients to compliment the delicious beers they brew right on site. It wouldn’t make sense to put so much effort into brewing fantastic beer and then not having fantastic food to complement it would it?

“Haven't had something that I don't like here! Love their cheese curds, elote dip, and their pesto cream cheese dip! All very good! The charcuterie board is okay but I don't think I'll order it again. I love trying something new when I go there! All their entrees are great! Can't wait to go back!” - Yelp Review 

5. Shift Kitchen & Bar

Upscale food in a comforting environment. 

107 N San Francisco Street | Downtown | shiftflg.com

Shift aims to, well, shift the way you think of the “normal” dining experience. Basically, they want to shake up your perception. They serve a highly curated menu in a laid back and friendly ambiance, which I really appreciate. The issue with so many high end restaurants is that you feel like you are walking on eggshells the whole time because they are so fancy. You don’t want to make the slightest mistake or any sort of social faux pas. You don’t have to worry about that at Shift, because even though their menu is pretty fancy and prepared, they serve it up in a very welcoming and inviting environment. 

“I was very impressed with Shift Kitchen and Bar when we first visited it; the service, the quality of the food, and the atmosphere are all first-tier.” - Yelp Review 

6. Sonic

Classic American Cheeseburger in Downtown Flagstaff

Buy a digital Sonic gift card

1327 E Butler Ave | Downtown | sonicdrivein.com/az

Sonic is one of those chains that is so big and popular I probably don’t need to explain them. But if you don’t know, they offer up classic American cheeseburgers with an extensive and creative drink menu. And listen, there are all sorts of reasons you might be looking for restaurants in downtown Flagstaff, Arizona. I don’t know if you need a quick bite to eat, or if you are trying to impress a big date, so I like to cover both options. If you are in downtown Flagstaff and are looking for a great burger, then look no further. Sonic is gonna be the place for you if you need lunch and you need it now.

“The food is always hot and fresh, and the happy hour drinks are such a great deal...and it's one of the few places in town you can get a milkshake after 10pm :-). Also the app usually works great and has lots of deals so despite the error today it's normally worth it. I recommend this Sonic to everybody.” - Yelp Review 

Buy a digital Sonic gift card

7. Cornish Pasty Co.

An old pastry brought to life. 

26 S San Francisco St | Downtown | cornishpastyco.com

Cornish Pasty Co. is a restaurant that serves an old English treat called cornish pasties. They originated from 1200s England in mining towns, and is a calzone-like pastry with a filling and a crimped edge. Cornish Pasty Co. took this historical dish and made it their staple. When you visit them, you will get a long list of cornish pasties to choose from. They offer signature pasties, premium ones, and even vegan pasties. 

Try the pork and apple signature pasty or the hatch chili burger, a Cubano or a pesto chicken premium pasty, or a vegan vindaloo or vegan pot pie pasty if you want something meatless. This meal will be a comforting one that will introduce you to bold new flavors. 

“Cornish Pasty in Tempe is a favorite destination for some comfort food. The Rosemary steak is tasty but the Carne Adovada Meat Pies is my absolute favorite. They have a nice chill patio area where you can bring your dog. Good food and service is the reason I come back again and again.”–Yelp Review

8. The Toasted Owl Cafe

Little owl decor and good breakfast. 

12 S Mikes Pike St | Downtown | thetoastedowl.com

The Toasted Owl was founded in 2013 based on the owner’s dreams. This restaurant’s namesake comes from what the owner collects. She collects little owls and places them all over her restaurant as decorations. This restaurant is open for breakfast each day and always serves $7 mimosas. Their popular breakfast items include their buttermilk pancakes, biscuits & gravy, & their Spanish omelets. You won’t regret having breakfast there!

“What a kitschy and cute place to eat! I ordered lunch while my husband ordered breakfast. Had a huge patio but it was a little chilly so we chose to eat inside. Owls of every shape and size plus dozens of T-shirts decorate the walls, unique light fixtures hang from the ceiling, and everything is for sale. Hubs had the French toast while I had the fried chicken sandwich. both tasty. Would return again!”–Yelp Review

9. Satchmo’s

Southern barbeque that is made fresh daily. 

2320 N 4th St | Downtown | satchmosaz.com

Satchmo’s is a cajun, creole, and barbeque restaurant that serves Southern comfort food. The owners take foods that have been around for generations and put their own spin on it. So their food is not exactly made the way that the average southern grandparents would make it, but it is made with plenty of love all the same. 

This restaurant makes their foods fresh daily. They make their own cajun spice blends, cast iron cornbread, soups & stocks, and of course, their slow smoked barbeque paired with hand-blended rubs. 

“I love this place! They have the best ribs and cornbread in the world. They also serve a really interesting coleslaw too. It's not fancy but it's friendly with a good vibe and as I mentioned, great food!”–Yelp Review

10. MartAnne’s Burrito Palace

The best Mexican breakfast in town, served all day. 

112 E Rt 66 | Downtown | martannes.com

MartAnne’s Burrito Palace is a family owned Mexican restaurant that has been voted Flagstaff’s best breakfast! Their breakfast menu includes lots of Mexican classics that the city loves. There are their famous breakfast chilaquiles, eggs rancheros, enchiladas, and more. Their breakfast is served all day, and it’s all served with rice, beans, hash browns, and a flour tortilla. 

“So great! We were looking for a breakfast place open on Monday's and stopped in to MartAnne's... what a find! Ordered Elote and chips as an appetizer and it was super yummy! Ate so much it ruined my ability to finish my breakfast... The beef tamale was so flavorful, the El gringo breakfast was really good, but again, I couldn't finish it. Highly recommend this place!”–Yelp Review

11. Diablo Burger

Fresh and delicious burgers cooked to order. 

120 N Leroux St | Downtown | diabloburger.com

Diablo Burger is a burger joint that serves open-range raised, antibiotic and hormone free beef straight from the Diablo Trust ranches. Their burgers are 95% lean, so they recommend that you enjoy them medium rare. But they know that medium rare is not for everyone, and so make their burgers at the full range of heat settings. They offer several signature burgers, each with a unique and delicious blend of toppings that you will love. 

“This place is SO GOOD. I used to come here years ago when I was at NAU. We got the Señor Smoke (my fav) and the Wrigley Field. The quality and service is still OUTSTANDING. We left happy with full bellies. Yum!”–Yelp Review

12. The Northern Pines Restaurant

Mouthwatering creations made with fresh ingredients.

2200 E Butler Ave | Downtown | thenorthernpines.com

The Northern Pines is a restaurant that is sophisticated but still family friendly. It is a locally owned restaurant that desires to present an authentic Flagstaff experience. Their high quality meals are very well priced, and absolutely mouth watering. They only use the most delicious and pure ingredients including real butter, Satchmo’s seasonings, and steaks aged by Randall’s Fine Meats. Their delicious food will have you wanting to go back again and again!

“Great local spot! Spent the night in Flagstaff and had breakfast here. It was a pleasant atmosphere and the food was great! Would recommend and go back.”–Yelp Review

That is my list of the best restaurants you can find in downtown Flagstaff. I hope you found what you're looking for. And if you're willing to expand your search from downtown Flagstaff, to just Flagstaff itself, you can also check out one of our other great articles on different styles of restaurants you can find around the city!


Written by

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Learn more

Related Articles

All Related Articles

Related Articles

All Related Articles