Best Italian Restaurants in Oklahoma City

Oklahoma City, the largest city in Oklahoma, is a bustling metropolis filled with people from all walks of life.

Entrepreneurs and business owners alike flock to Oklahoma City to bring the locals new and exciting experiences. For this reason, you'll find some of the best restaurants in Oklahoma City. From Chinese to American to Italian food, Oklahoma City has it all. Today, we'll be focusing on Italian food because who doesn't love Italian food? We're talking delicious bruschetta, mouth-watering spaghetti and meatballs, and tasty desserts like tiramisu. You'll be craving Italian food by the end of this article.

Is a loved one's birthday coming up? We recommend a GiftYa virtual gift card! GiftYa offers virtual gift cards to a variety of places all over the country. You can find gift cards for local merchants and restaurants and give your friend or family member the gift of a new experience. And if they happen to love Italian food, then the good news is GiftYa has gift cards to all the Italian places we list below.

Vito’s Ristorante

A restaurant and bar serving fine Italian cuisine in a jovial atmosphere.

Image courtesy of Vito’s Ristorante.

7628 N May Ave | Oklahoma City |

Vito's Ristorante is a true trattoria, an Italian restaurant serving classic Italian food. It was established in 2004 by the owner Cathy Cummings who wanted to bring her Italian heritage to the locals. All the recipes in Vito's Ristorante have been in her family for generations and her family has been running Italian restaurants for as long as she can remember.

Family is extremely important to Cathy and this shows as the restaurant is a tribute to her family. When you walk into the restaurant, you can see pictures of her family covering the walls which give it a homey feel and immediately puts you at ease. The decor and atmosphere resemble a little Italian bistro.

Not only do you get a fun family vibe from Vito’s, but they also have amazing Italian food with a large menu to choose from. Peruse their antipasti, salad, pasta, house specialties, and more. Try their Chicken Spedini, strips of chicken covered in Italian seasoned bread crumbs in grilled to perfection. Then these crispy strips of chicken are topped with amogio, a traditional Sicilian sauce that's light and citrusy. Yum!

"Our favorite Italian restaurant. The staff makes you feel like you are family. The food is always wonderful. Homemade focaccia is wonderful and they keep it coming. They have the best mussels on linguine. The Fettuccine Alfredo is so creamy. We have been eating here for over a decade. The service and food are always great." - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Vito's Ristorante.


A warm and comfortable restaurant with an elegant atmosphere serving rustic Italian cuisine.

Image courtesy of Patrono.

305 N Walker Ave | Oklahoma City |

Patrono is one of those unique restaurants that would make a perfect place for a date night with their warm colors and elegant atmosphere while also being a comfortable dining area for a family. It's located in the Avana Arts District in Oklahoma City serving up amazing Italian fare along with imported wines. This is a locale to consider for your next date night.

Chef Jonathan Krell aims to bring his guests Italian ingredients and Italian techniques in conventional and unconventional ways for an experience they'll never forget. Perusing their menu shows how much work Chef Krell puts into his dishes. Start with a delicious appetizer of Warm Olives and Marcona Almonds marinated in rosemary, orange zest, and olive oil. Enjoy an amazing entree of Spicy Crab and Shrimp Campanelle. Campanelle is a type of pasta that's shaped similar to a bellflower with a little ruffled edge. You'll find some unique meals at Patrono.

"Let me get straight to the point. Happiness, that is what I am feeling. Not only was I greeted immediately by Robert with a smile, the atmosphere welcomed me and music softly sang to my soul. This small gem of a restaurant made my day. My server gave me a wine and entree recommendation that perfectly paired. I never take leftovers but I didn't want to waste a crumb. Everything is made from scratch and textures compliment each other. Well done! Already planned date night here with the hubs." - Yelp Review

Purchase GiftYa card for Patrono.

Moni’s Pasta & Pizza

A lively and casual restaurant delivering pizza, pasta, and other Italian specialties.

Image courtesy of Moni’s Pasta & Pizza.

17200 N May Ave #700 | Edmond |

When you first walk into Moni’s, you know you'll be having a memorable experience. It has a modern trendy vibe with brick walls and a vibrant red ceiling. Their food is incredible and they have many options to choose from. Try a Moni’s Salad with romaine, green leaf lettuce, spinach, kalamata olives, red onions, green bell peppers, tricolored tomatoes, and shaved parmesan.

If you’re in the mood for seafood, try their Nero e Verde, steamed green and black mussels in lemon, garlic, and Chardonnay. They also offer pizzas and you can build your own pizza or pasta. And finally, finish the entire meal with a delicious Limoncello Cake.

Moni’s was established in 2014 by John and Rachel Foster. With Rachel's background in cooking and John’s interest in business, they opened Moni's Pasta and Pizza, a casual locale that would soon become one of Oklahoma City's favorite Italian restaurants.

"This place was wonderful! Nice atmosphere and great service. Taylor was our server and she was great.  They start you off with warm fresh rolls and some olive oil and seasoning. Delicious!  I had the lunch portion of lasagna which I still took home some of. Great portions size. Definitely will be back!" - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Moni’s Pasta & Pizza.

Gabriella’s Italian Grill

A chef-owned restaurant serving up refined homestyle Italian food.

Image courtesy of Gabriella’s Italian Grill.

1226 NE 63rd St | Oklahoma City |

Gabriella’s Italian Grill is owned and operated by Chef Vicki whose family has been in the restaurant business serving traditional Italian cuisine since 1953. So when it comes to Italian food, Chef Vicki knows her stuff. Gabriella's Italian Grill is located in the heart of the Adventure District in Oklahoma City and offers a family-friendly atmosphere. It's a chic and comfortable restaurant that has an outdoor eating area if you like to enjoy your food outdoors.

Browse their menu and you'll find all kinds of delicious Italian food including Mussels Italiano made with spicy blue shell mussels sauteed with bacon, shallots, garlic, poblano peppers, white wine, and butter. Delicious! Or try their Pasta La Tonno, made with yellowfin tuna sauteed with garlic, sun-dried tomatoes, and roasted red peppers. Then it’s smothered in a tomato cream sauce and topped with truffle oil. Chef Vicki is a genius and it shows in her menu.

"This is our special date night place. I have never had anything bad here. The desserts are amazing as well. We normally have the same server and I wish I could remember his name. He is wonderful and I'm ashamed I can't remember his name. The other times he hasn't served us, the server was great too. We love everything about this place." - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Gabriella’s Italian Grill.

Stella Modern Italian Cuisine

A modern and chic restaurant crafting inventive Italian pasta, entrees, and brick oven pizzas.

Image courtesy of Stella Modern Italian Cuisine.

1201 N Walker Ave | Oklahoma City |

The owner of Stella Modern Italian Cuisine, Lori Burson, spent time studying in Rome where she fell in love with the food and the philosophy around food. Italian people didn't eat in a hurry but rather gathered with friends and family making every meal a celebration. This message resonated with Lori who opened Stella Modern Italian Cuisine in 2010 wanting to share this philosophy and delicious Italian food with the locals in Oklahoma City. It's no surprise to anyone that Stella became a staple in Oklahoma City for serving up delicious Italian food and amazing pizza.

Just like Lori wanted, Stella is a place where friends and family can come and enjoy each other's company along with the delicious meal. Not only does Stella have a fun and memorable vibe, but the food is also amazing. The Wood-Fired brick oven is the centerpiece of the restaurant so it would make sense you might want to try their oak-fired pizzas. It's a pizza that will have you coming back for more. If you're wanting a pasta dish, you have to try the Beef and Sausage Lasagna made with herbed ricotta, fontina, mozzarella, and parmesan smothered in Pomodoro sauce. This is one tasty place.

"As soon as you walk in you feel special!  The bar is where we sat and it is a beautiful one at that.  There were 6 of us for drinks a few apps so it worked out perfectly.

The atmosphere overall is casual yet classy.  We all noticed the lights.  The service is low key-helpful-professional.  Everyone is super knowledgable and gave great advice.

We had the bruschetta plus 2 pizzas:  Pear and Prosciutto and the Exotic Mushroom.  Everything was delicious.  Our drinks were each different and just right.  We ordered off the House Specialty Cocktails and wine list.  Just right!

Stop in and enjoy Stellas. You'll be glad you did." - Yelp Review

Purchase a GifYa card to Stella Modern Italian Cuisine.

Papa Dio’s Italian Restaurant

An Italian restaurant and wine bar featuring an expansive menu of pasta, veal entrees, chicken entrees, and pizza.

Image courtesy of Papa Dio’s Italian Restaurant.

10712 N May Ave | Oklahoma City |

Papa Dio's is a very unique establishment. It’s Oklahoma City's oldest family-owned Italian restaurant that's actually run by Italians. So you know you're getting the best authentic Italian food. Start with the Pesto Bruschetta and end with a delicious dessert like Tiramisu. When it comes to picking your entree you'll have a tough time choosing with their huge menu. You can choose your own pasta with chunky marinara, red tomato sauce with meat or sausage, white or red clam sauce, alfredo al dio, or even a trieste sauce which is a combination of alfredo sauce, pesto sauce, and red sauce. If you're in the mood for pizza, make sure to try one of their fried pizzas which you'll certainly be craving again.

One unique aspect of this restaurant is that it actually has two dining rooms. One is a casual dining room for family and friends to hang out and enjoy each other's company. The other dining room is romantic with fine dining and a lovely atmosphere. So whether you’re chilling with friends or you have a hot date, Papa Dio’s is a winner.

"This was my first time here. The ambiance was delightful- so much warmth, Sinatra playing in the background, and dimly lit- the perfect Italian concoction. The service was wonderful. The food was delicious! I got the Chicken Del Greco & wow, THE BEST light & buttery sauce! You must come & try this hidden gem." - Yelp Review.

Purchase a GiftYa card for Papa Dio’s Italian Restaurant.

From Italian appetizers to Italian desserts, you can find the best and most delicious Italian restaurants in Oklahoma City. Each restaurant has its own unique menu and atmosphere giving its guests an experience to remember. Out of the restaurants we've gone over today, which one stands out to you the most? Leave us a comment below.

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts

Food & Drink
11 Best Restaurants for Breakfast + Brunch in Boise

From Sizzling Bacon to Fluffy Pancakes, Here Are the Best Places to Fuel Up with Breakfast and Brunch in The Gem State

Food & Drink
12 Restaurants That Serve the Best Brunch in Portland

From Pastries Shops to Old School Diners, Local Joints to National Chains, Here are the Absolute Best Places for Breakfast and Brunch in Portland, Oregon