Craving Cheesy Goodness? These Restaurants Serve The Best Pizza In Colorado Springs!

Get every topping you can think of or just go with plain cheese, whatever you choose these spots can provide!

Pizza — it’s one of the most popular foods in the country. It’s savory, versatile, and usually inexpensive, meaning it’s the perfect food as it’s suitable for a variety of different occasions. So it’s no wonder that pizza is so popular in Colorado Springs as well! And if you find yourself craving a fresh, cheesy slice of pizza then luckily for you, the Springs is home to dozens of great pizza parlors to check out. We’ve compiled a list of the restaurants with the best pizza in Colorado Springs. Read on for more info!

Searching for the perfect gift for your loved ones? Surprise them with a virtual GiftYa card! GiftYa offers hundreds of e-cards for popular shops and restaurants around the city, including some in Colorado Springs. Within seconds, you can send your best friend and/or family member a virtual gift card to their favorite restaurant, retailer, or online store. 

Check out the full selection of gift cards and see how you can customize your own GiftYa here!

1. Fat Sully’s Pizza

New York style pizza conveniently served late into the night in Colorado Springs

528 S Tejon St | Colorado Springs | fatsullys.com

If you want to enjoy savory and authentic New York style pizza, you need to visit Fat Sully’s. This popular pizzeria has been featured on numerous networks and shows including the Food Network, CNN, Triple-D Nation, and Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives. 

The menu is short and simple. Fat Sully’s serves massive slices and 26” pies which are dine-in only. 

Gluten-free 12” pies are also available. Guests can choose between white sauce or red sauce and add numerous toppings such as jalapenos, pineapples, and artichoke hearts. And if you’re looking for a side they do have fries, wings, loaded garlic knots, dessert knots, a burger, a chicken sammie, and two salads. Don’t forget to finish your pizza off with some dip like ranch or blue cheese dressing!

“Food was awesome!! Service was also awesome. We sat upstairs and the view was GORGEOUS. We tried the Sully's Fries, two slices of pizza, and a shake. It was delicious. Will be coming back!” -Yelp Review

2. Pizzeria Rustica

Cozy pizzeria known for its Neapolitan thin-crust pies

2527 W Colorado Ave | Colorado Springs | pizzeriarustica.com

Pizzeria Rustica offers a cozy and rustic atmosphere that will take you back to classic Italy. Located inside a historic 1899 building, this charming eatery will immediately sweep you off your feet. Throughout the years, it has garnered numerous awards including Best Restaurant of 2009, “Nine Perfect 10s” of 2008, and Best Pizze of 2010.

You’ll find a variety of special pizza options, such as the Regina Super Margherita and Quattro Stagioni. Numerous vegetarian options are also available. Hungry for dessert? Pizzeria Rustica offers delicious desserts such as the House Made Cannoli and Fresh Baked Cookie & Gelato.

“Great pizza and great service! Thank you Bridgid for taking such good care of us!
We had a caprese salad, cheese pizza for my son and a salumi pizza, everything was delicious!” -Yelp Review

3. Bambino's Urban Pizzeria

Laid back pizza parlor perfect for casual get-togethers

36 E Bijou St | Colorado Springs | bambinosurbanpizzeria.com

At Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria, you can enjoy fresh and savory slices of Neapolitan pizza made from high-quality, artisan ingredients. All of the 11 1/2” pizzas are also made from scratch daily. You will be able to customize almost everything about your pizza, including the base, cheese, meat, and veggies. 

Special pizzas are also available, such as the Spicy Pig and the Leave it to Beefer. Coming with the kids? Bambino’s also offers 6” pizzas that come with a free drink. Bambino’s is the perfect spot for your next family dinner!

“While checking out Colorado Springs, we came across this cool-looking (and GREAT smelling) pizza shop. The food was incredible and the staff was very nice and hospitable. Our eyes were bigger than our stomachs so keep this in mind when you order. We had a TON of food!” -Yelp Review

4. Duca's Neapolitan Pizza

Delicious pizza made from scratch daily with low-gluten dough!

a close up a half eaten pizza pie with cheese, pepperoni, and other meat on top
Enjoy some of the best pizza in Colorado Springs in house or at home! Image courtesy of Duca’s Neapolitan Pizza’s Yelp photo page.

236 E Cheyenne Mountain Blvd | Colorado Springs | ducaspizza.com

Duca’s Neapolitan Pizza specializes in a centuries-old pizza making technique mastered by Neapolotian chefs. Every morning, the chefs make low-gluten dough from scratch. Fresh mozzarella cheese, basil, sweet tomatoes, and olive oil are all added to the pie before it is thrown into a handmade brick wood fired oven. 

Both classic and specialty pizzas are available, such as the Margherita, Capricciosa, and Buffalo Chicken Pizza. If you order a classic option, you can add various proteins, cheeses, and vegetables to finish it off. Yum!

“Best pizza I've had. Authentic and delicious, many to choose on the menu but not an overwhelming amount on the menu. Simple and straight to the point. Clean restaurant and the service is great” -Yelp Review

5. Leon Gessi Pizza

Popular parlor known for its New York style pizza!

a close up of a half eaten pizza pie, this pizza is topped with sauce, cheese, pepperoni, black olives, and mushrooms
Nothing beats a close up picture of a delicious looking pizza! Image courtesy of the Leon Gessi New York Pizza Yelp photo page.

1806 Palmer Park Blvd | Colorado Springs | leongessipizza.com

Looking for a casual spot to hang out and kick back with friends? Leon Gessi Pizza might become your new favorite pizza spot! This laidback restaurant offers delicious New York style pizza made from freshly-prepared ingredients. 

Guests can order by the slice or get a 14” cheese pizza or 16” specialty pizza. Additional toppings such as Canadian bacon and homemade meatballs are also available, making it easy to create your dream pizza.

“Great little family owned place. Service is great and the pizza is delicious! I love all kinds of pizza but I loved how fresh tasting theirs was. Definitely one of my favorites here in the Springs.” -Yelp Review

6. Savelli’s Pizza

Fresh, made-to-order pizza served in a casual space

301 Manitou Ave | Manitou Springs | savellis-pizza.com

At Savalli’s, you can enjoy fresh, made-to-order pizza filled with homemade dough and pasta sauce. Since 1998, locals have picked Savalli’s as one of their favorite pizzerias. Specialty, stone-baked, and gluten-free pizzas are all served at this popular restaurant. 

Some of their most popular pies are the Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza, Veggie Lover Pizza, and BBQ Chicken Pizza. If you’re a little picky about what’s on your pizza, you can customize your own! Dozens of savory toppings are available for you to choose from.

“If you're wanting local pizza and fun and friendly service, this is your place! I will choose Savellis over Dominos, Hells Kitchen, Slice 420, etc - every time! Amazing ingredients and family friendly. Good to go too!” -Yelp Review

7. Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana

Authentic Neapolitan pizza served inside a rustic atmosphere

9278 Forest Bluffs View #100 | Colorado Springs | basilandbarley.com

Basil & Barley Pizzeria is known for its savory and authentic Neapolitan pizzas. Made using only the finest and freshest ingredients, these popular pizzas will delight your taste buds and fill you right up. 

Numerous specialty pizzas are featured on the menu, including the Capricciosa, Suprema, and their very own Basil & Barley! Along with their pizzas they also have a number of classic Neapolitan fried starters, salads, wings, homemade desserts, and a wide range of craft cocktails, beer, and wine.

“Excellent food and even better service! Definitely try the house salad and add the Italian dressing, so good! The pizza was fresh and very well composed. 10/10! Make sure to ask for Niki, she made sure our experience was special.” -Yelp Review

8. Ruffrano’s Hell’s Kitchen Pizza

Best New York style pizza found right around Colorado Springs!

9 Ruxton Ave | Manitou Springs | ruffranosmenu.com

Next on the list is Ruffrano’s Hell’s Kitchen Pizza. This popular pizzeria is known for its fresh and savory New York style pies. Over a dozen specialty pizzas such as the Mac & Cheese and Deep Dish Sicillian are offered on the restaurant’s extensive menu. Not hungry for the whole pie? No problems! They sell pizza by the slice. Chicken wings, salads, calzones, and more are also served at this popular pizzeria!

“this pizza place is fluffing amazing !!!! the best gluten free pizza I have ever had !!! the price is so affordable. the rest of my party had a slice of pizza with garlic knots, they devoured them quickly. we left with happy and full tummies” -Yelp Review

9. Fargo’s Pizza

A Victorian-style restaurant with handmade pizzas and salads!

2910 E Platte Ave | Colorado Springs | fargospizza.com

Fargo’s Pizza is unlike any other pizza place you’ve been to in Colorado Springs. Their interior is a Victorian Old West Saloon and sometimes you’ll see people dressed up walking around like you took a ride back into the past!

Go through their “World Famous” salad bar and then take a glance at their pizzas where you can get pies like the Italian Sausage Pizza, Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Vegetarian Pizza, and regular Cheese Pizza. There’s also pasta, sandwiches, desserts, and more. Don’t miss out on this intriguing pizza spot!

“I love this place. It hasn't changed since I was a child but in all of the best ways. It's good and the experience is delightful. Service was great. I had the personal pizza and salad bar special for $10.” -Yelp Review

10. Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders

Pizza, hoagies, and other favorites are all served right here!

a table full of food, there's a white pizza with veggie toppings on the left, a basket of fries and a chili cheese steak, a plate of a calzone-like dish with dipping sauce on the side, a basket of buffalo wings, and a basket of garlic knot breadsticks
Nothing quite like a nice greasy, carb-loaded treat at the end of the week! Image courtesy of the Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders Yelp photo page.

5490 Powers Center Point #180 | Colorado Springs | piesandgrinders.com

Come to Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders for some homemade, always fresh pizza that’s made to order so each customer gets quality food. This spectacular restaurant has everything that you will need when it comes to delicious pizzas, hoagies, and other “pizza shop” classics.

They have a “Grinders & Phillies” section where you can enjoy sammies like the Chicken Parmesan, Spicy BBQ Pork, and the classic Cheesesteak. They’ve also got calzones, strombolis, wings, salads, and a list of a few beers and wine. For their pizza try out the Sweet and Spicy Salami, Pork Green Chili, or the Garlic Chicken. 

“We hadn't been to Pies & Grinders in quite a while & after this visit, we will definitely be a more frequent patron. The pizza is incredible!!! You taste the quality in every bite & the positivity is a vibe throughout. Keep doing what you're doing! Absolutely delicious!!” -Yelp Review

11. Pizza Time Colorado

This place has everything that you are looking for in a pizza shop!

a close up of a classic pepperoni and cheese pizza
Nothing beats a classic! Pepperoni and cheese is always a good go-to! Image courtesy of the Pizza Time Yelp photo page.

8794 N Union Blvd | Colorado Springs | pizzatimecolorado.com

There is nothing better than a pizza place that just seems to have it all. From subs, wraps, salads, pasta, lunch specials, gluten-free options, and of course, pizza, you need to experience the family owned Pizza Time Colorado ASAP! This place even offers outdoor dining so you can enjoy a relaxing time outdoors when the weather is nice while eating your pizza and more.

Make sure to check out Pizza Time Colorado so you can try out everything from  their menu including specialty pizzas like the Spinach Alfredo, Five Cheese, Taco Pizza, and the “Take N’ Bake” which is where they provide the materials and you get to bake it at home! 

“I really enjoyed the pizza and sandwiches. My kids loved spending what little money I have left on the games! Pair it all with a good beer a few blocks from my house and I'm a happy camper!” -Yelp Review

12. Parry’s Pizza and Taphouse

Pizza and beer is an amazing combo, and that’s what this place specializes in!

1268 Interquest Pkwy #100 | Colorado Springs | parryspizza.com

If you’re a fan of beer, and you’re a fan of pizza, and you happen to be a fan of both together then make sure to check out Parry’s Pizza and Taphouse where you can enjoy a unique and delicious pizza pie along with a beer or two as well. They are also known for their amazing appetizers like Parmesan or Fire Fries and Pretzel & Beer Cheese, along with chicken wings, and pizza of course! Get one of their specialty pies like the Soho Veggie or the Buffalo Chicken for a rockin good time.

“Our favorite casual date night place to eat, drink and hang out. We love sitting at the bar with the awesome bar crew. Great selection of beer, multiple TVs for sports and love the atmosphere. Try the cheesy bread!” -Yelp Review

13. Blackjack Pizzas & Salads

Counter-service offering a range of tasty pizza and other foods!

1915 W Uintah St | Colorado Springs | blackjackpizza.com

Are you someone that enjoys the pizza and salad combination? If you do, then Blackjack Pizzas & Salads in Colorado Springs is awaiting your arrival. This spectacular restaurant is known for their delicious pizza and salads, this chain has got a lot of fun options like the Garlic Buffalo Chicken pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, and the Honey Sriracha Pizza with their fair share of calzones, cheesy bread, wings, desserts, and salads of course.

“Ordered the Santa Fe pizza off Uber eats! Wow delicious ! I didn't expect it to be that good! Every bite had a nice spice to it! I ordered the pan and the crust was amazing as well!” -Yelp Review

14. Il Vicino Wood Oven Pizza

Traditional pizzas being served in a lively casual space!

5214 N Nevada Ave | Colorado Springs | ilvicino.com

A group of friends who have been working in the restaurant industry for years decided to take their own knowledge and create a space where good food and good people can unite under one roof. And at II Vicino you’ll get to see this well oiled machine in action as they have been cooking up authentic wood-fired pies for over 30 years!

They’ve got salads, pastas, paninis, desserts, and their fair share of pizza choices like the Margherita, Molta Carne, Meatball, and the Bianca. Or build your own from scratch and choose from many different toppings.

“I've been here twice now and the food is phenomenal!! Their pizza is delicious and their spicy oil for the crust is a must have. Also- do NOT leave without trying a cannoli!!!! They are SO SO good.” -Yelp Review

15. Billy's Old World Pizza

Authentic handmade award winning Italian food!

a close up picture of a Chicago style deep dish "Special Pizza" which contains Sausage, mushroom, onion and green peppers with added pepperoni half eaten on a metal tray above a checkered table

Calling all of our deep dish pizza lovers! Image courtesy of the Billy’s Old World Pizza Yelp photo page.

308 S 8th St Unit E | Colorado Springs | billysoldworldpizza.com

Coming from a Chicago background, Billy’s Old World Pizza is serving up authentic Italian flavors as everything is made with the freshest ingredients. Everything is made in house and made to order so you know you’ll be dining on quality foods. They are here to make the best of the best pizza and their range of different types of pizza is greatly appreciated. They’ve got “Thin & Crispy” and “Chicago Style Stuffed Deep Dish.” So you can pick which style you like more and chow down!

“We had the thin crust special with sausage, mushrooms, onions and green pepper. It was LOADED with all of the above and tons of cheese!!! SO worth the price. Glad we stopped!” -Yelp Review

16. High Rise Pizza Kitchen

Hand-made dough is why they’ve got some of the best pizza in Colorado Springs!

a close up of a perfectly round pizza with sauce, mozzarella cheese, and basil
A pizza that both tastes good and looks good? That’s top tier! Image courtesy of the High Rise Pizza Kitchen Yelp photo page.

6660 Delmonico Dr F | Colorado Springs | highrisepizzakitchen.com

Serving fresh, locally sourced ingredients, High Rise Pizza Kitchen has a range of menu items you’ll love to try like:

  • 16” “Chef’s Specials” Pizzas: Chicken Bacon Ranch and “Pig Newton”
  • 16” “House Favorites” Pizzas: High Rise Margherita and the “ Supreme Being”
  • And a BYO Pizza section where you can choose from a list of over 20 toppings!
  • (There’s more on the menu like cheesy bread and salads, but their speciality is pizza and that’s why they are on this list of the best pizza in Colorado Springs)!

“The food and service was amazing. Cason was so kind to my husband and I. We just got married and we stopped in for the first time. He was very kind and genuine. The margarita pizza was delicious” -Yelp Review

17. Poor Richard's Restaurant

Brick-oven pizza, sandwiches, salads, and vegetarian/vegan friendly!

324 1/2 N Tejon St | Colorado Springs | poorrichardsrestaurant.com

Since 1977, this well loved establishment has been serving some of the best food you can find in Colorado Springs. Poor Richard’s Restaurant makes delicious menu items like their famous 18” New York Style Pizza and their sandwiches which are all on locally-based breads. There’s also gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan menu items so everyone can have a bite to eat at Poor Richard’s Restaurant! 

“This is our first time here and love everything. Everyone is nice even the owner greeted us and was helpful. We will keep this on the radar and come back again. Thank you Poor Richard's the food is great.” -Yelp Review

18. Roman Villa Pizza

Family-run, local Italian food perfect for a delicious weekend’s dinner!

a close up of a pizza with cheese, green peppers, black olives, onions, and mushrooms on a wooden table
Lots of toppings on a pizza is a must for some people and they do it right! Image courtesy of the Roman Villa Pizza Yelp photo page.

3005 N Nevada Ave | Colorado Springs | romanvillaonline.weebly.com

In 1959 Roman Villa Pizza opened and started cooking up plates of “mouth-watering” Italian dishes and they continue to go strong today. This family owned restaurant has learned a lot over the years and they continue to astound all patrons who walk through their hungry and ready to eat. Get a 10 or 12 inch pizza and choose from a list of meats and other toppings. There’s also pasta, salads, and garlic bread.

“This place hits all the marks ! Delicious authentic food , friendly and engaging staff who work their tails off and never stop moving and working hard .. there is love in this food .. Thank you ! We will go far out of our way to come here again !” -Yelp Review

Whew! There you have it! These restaurants are serving the best pizza in Colorado Springs and they are eagerly awaiting your order.

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts

Food & Drink
Enjoy An Incredible Night At Any Of These Downtown Charleston Restaurants

We’ve got an array of incredible dishes served up from some of Charleston’s best!

Food & Drink
Black Owned Restaurants In Charleston, SC

Black Owned restaurants are thriving in the city of Charleston.