Where to Find the Best Sandwiches in Chicago

There are few things in life more satisfying than taking a bite out of a savory sandwich after a long day at work. Whether you are in the mood for a grilled cheese sandwich or a BLT, Chicago offers a plethora of restaurants that offer some of the tastiest sandwiches in the city. But where can customers find the best sandwiches in Chicago? While you probably won’t be able to find a solid consensus on the best sandwich maker in the city, you can still try out the most popular Chicago sandwich places before deciding for yourself. 

Still looking for a birthday present for your cousin? Need to get a last-minute gift for your nephew’s graduation? Treat them with a personalized GiftYa virtual gift card. All GiftYa cards are completely customizable. Since they are virtual, users can take the cards with them wherever they go. After you finish picking out the perfect card, add a personal message as a final touch. Then, you’re good to go! 


Castaways Bar & Grill

1603 N Lake Shore Dr. Lincoln Park | castawayschicago.com

Dine on Savory Food and Refreshing Drinks by the North Avenue Beach

Sip on a cocktail by the beach. Image courtesy of Yelp

Chicago might be located in a Mid-Western state, but that doesn’t mean its residents can’t treat themselves to a beach day every once in a while. Located along the North Avenue Beach, Castaways Bar and Grill is the premier destination for enjoying tropical drinks by the beach. Each day, the bar offers a new Daily Drink special for new and returning guests to try out. Along with their great location by the beach and their savory meals, Castaways Bar and Grill also offers live entertainment every weekend.

Are you just here for the sandwiches? No worries. Customers can choose from an extensive selection of sandwiches, including the Caribbean Jerk Chicken Sandwich, Turkey Perso, Turkey Griller, Ranch Chicken Griller, and Steak Croissant. 

Buy a GiftYa to Castaways Bar & Grill >

“How can you not give this place 5 stars. It's always Lit especially on weekends. The service here is fast and the food shows up fast too. It's so hopping you have to snag your own seats. You get a 180-degree view of the coast. Go to the other side of this boat shape place and you get the other 180. We had the fish tacos, chicken wings both buffalo and BBQ that and the popcorn shrimp all were fine.” - Yelp Review

Old Town Pour House

1419 N Wells St, Old Town | Near North Side | oldtownpourhouse.com

Order a Beer Before Chowing Down on a Hearty Sandwich

Feeling extra hungry? Order the heavyweight burger the next time you stop in. 

Need something hearty and nutritious to get you through the rest of your day? Try one of the Old Town Pour House’s famous sandwiches. Their eclectic sandwich options include Filet Mignon Sliders, a Fried Chicken Sandwich, Buffalo Chicken Sandwich, and more. As you wait for your sandwich, select a beer from one of the 90 options the bar has on tap. 

The Old Town Pour House also hosts a variety of events, including Trivia Tuesdays and film screenings. Fans of the restaurant can also purchase t-shirts, mugs, and gift cards in the store shop. With its energetic and vibrant atmosphere, the Old Town Pour House is the perfect destination for your next Happy Hour drinks or family dinner. 

Buy a GiftYa to Old Town Pour House >

“Food: we ordered the wings first, they were truly smoked! OMG they fell right off the bone the bbq sauce on the wide was perfectly sweet and tangy. Next we ordered the duck nachos, just GREAT! all the toppings really complemented the duck.” - Yelp Review

The Scout Waterhouse + Kitchen

1301 S Wabash Ave | Near Southside | thescoutchicago.com

Fill Your Belly With a Savory Sandwich and Side of Fries

Order the copy cat burger with a side of sweet potato fries. Image courtesy of Yelp.

Short Rib Grilled Cheeses, Backyard BBQ Chicken Sandwiches, Shrimp Po’Boys, and more await you at The Scout Waterhouse + Kitchen. Along with its eclectic sandwich offerings, the Scout Waterhouse + Kitchen also hosts private events and dinners for large parties. With full Brunch and Game Day menus, the restaurant is also a popular destination for pre-gaming festivities and get-togethers. If you’re stopping by for Game Day Brunch, make sure you try the Five Pepper Steak & Egg Sandwich with a glass of the Locked & Loaded Mimosa.

Buy a GiftYa to The Scout Waterhouse + Kitchen >

“The grilled cheese here is phenomenal...we specifically came for the foot-long grilled cheese, and it did not disappoint. The tomato bisque on the side is the perfect complement to the sandwich.”- Yelp Review

Bar Cargo

605 N Wells St, River North |Near North Side | barcargo.com

Wash Down Your Sandwich with a Cold Beer at This Popular North Side Destination

Relax along the Bar Cargo’s modern booths. Image courtesy of Time Out Chicago

Looking for the ultimate destination for hearty, Italian food? Look no further. Bar Cargo offers a savory menu featuring the restaurant’s signature Roman pizza, fried calamari, meatball sandwich, and more. All sandwiches are served with fries, which can be substituted for truffle fries or a side salad. If you need something to help wash down the sandwich, consider ordering a cocktail or can or beer from the restaurant’s comprehensive drink menu. Brunch is offered every Saturday and Sunday. Enjoy your selection of food from the brunch buffet and treat yourself with some bottomless mimosas for an unforgettable brunch.

Bar Cargo also offers plenty of space for group events. Groups of 12-150+ people can be accommodated in the restaurant’s vast space. In order to sufficiently feed these large groups, the party hosts will often select a special group menu provided by Bar Chicago. 

Buy a GiftYa to Bar Cargo >

“We had the hummus and tuna tartar appetizer and then ordered the chicken caprese sandwich and two pizzas (the queen and the hot hot hot). The appetizers and sandwich were great and the pizza was awesome. It's more Detroit style than Chicago but it's really good. The sauce and dough are homemade and tasted like they used really fresh ingredients. Everyone agreed that they were excellent.” - Yelp Review

Johnnie’s Beef

7500 W North Ave, Elmwood Park, IL


Chicago Eatery Famous for Delivering the City’s Favorite Beef Since 2005

Bite into one of the restaurant’s favorite subs or sandwiches. Image courtesy of Dining Out Challenge.

Italian food lovers from all over Chicago flock to Johnny’s Beef for its savory, authentic Italian cuisine. Italian sandwiches, char burgers, hot dogs, and gyros are just a few of the main menu items offered at Johnny’s Beef. Looking for something a little lighter? Johnny’s Beef also serves a variety of entree-sized salads. On the other hand, if you’re looking for something a little extra, you should definitely consider ordering one of the restaurant’s famous milkshakes.

Buy a GiftYa to Johnnie’s Beef >

“I ordered the combo sausage and beef sandwich with hot peppers, a side of fries, and small Italian ice. I'm convinced you have to order all three to get the full experience...The sandwich is definitely a wet sandwich, but the integrity of the bread holds up to the moisture from the meat juices. The beef is packed with flavor, but that sausage was amazing. Crisp outside, savory with some spice, everything you'd want from Italian sausage.” - Yelp Review



925 W Randolph St, West Loop, Near West Side | nonnaschicago.com

Take Your Next Lunch Inside This Popular Chicago Sandwich Shop

Order the Chicken Parmesan Sandwich the next time you’re in. Image courtesy of Yelp

Situated inside Chicago’s West Loop, Nonna’s serves as the prime destination for nourishing Italian meals. Customers can grab a quick meal on-the-go or enjoy their meal on the outdoor patio. 

Nonna’s menu includes a wide selection of made-to-order sandwiches, pizzas, desserts, and more. Sandwich lovers can choose between a savory selection of cold and hot sandwiches. Several of their most popular items include the Pacino Sandwich, Roasted Turkey Sandwich, and Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich. Feeling a little extra hungry? Make it a combo by adding chips and a soda. 

If you can’t get enough of Nonna’s famous sandwiches, consider hiring them as a caterer for your next event. Pick the “Brown Bag Lunch” option with a combination of a sandwich, chips, and a cookie or a Sandwich Platter if you have a larger group party. 

Buy a GiftYa to Nonna’s >

“Eggplant Parm sandwich. Outstanding. Loved it. The bread they used is lovely. Hearty. Firm. Mmmm...It comes with some extra marinara on the side, which makes it great. In cold sandwiches, they have one called the Mona Lisa. And again Muuaahh!! Delicious. Pesto sauce, veggies, fresh mozzarella. Same amazing bread. So good.” - Yelp Review

Chicago has an endless array of restaurants and delis fit for sandwiches lovers of all taste buds. Finding only one eatery to proclaim as the top destination for the best sandwiches in Chicago is just too difficult. What are your go-to sandwiches for lunch and dinner? Let us know in the comments below!

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts

12 Top Breakfast Places in Dallas You Need to Visit

Treat Yourself to a Delicious Breakfast with Friends and Family at These Popular Spots

When Were Gift Cards Invented? A History Through 2024

Our Crash Course in Everybody’s Favorite Versatile, All-Occasion Gift: The Humble Gift Card! Do You Know How It Has Evolved?