Top 11 Best Restaurants in Bar Harbor, Maine to Get the Best Lobster 🦞

Main image courtesy of The Travelin Lobster.

Bar Harbor is a beautiful town in Maine, and it also happens to be quite the tourist spot as well with its close proximity to one of our amazing national parks. Since you ended up on this webpage, we’re going to go ahead and guess that you are here because you are looking for some great lobster in the Bar Harbor area. You are in luck, because today we have just the thing you are looking for. 

That’s right, this is going to be a list of all the best lobster joints you can find around Bar Harbor. We’ll be sure to give you each restaurant's address so that way you can just have your GPS app take you to the front door, plus include a link to each restaurant's website so that you can check out their menu and pricing options ahead of time. On top of that, plenty of these amazing seafood restaurants around Bar Harbor accept our convenient and modern digital GiftYa gift cards. 

Purchase a GiftYa Gift Card as a Gift For Someone Looking For Fresh Lobster in Bar Harbor, Maine

Getting a gift for someone, whether it is for their birthday, anniversary, graduation, or any other special occasion calls for a GiftYa is a digital gift card that can be sent within seconds right from your phone. These gift cards can be used at a variety of locations but are particularly popular for restaurants. This is especially true if you are out traveling and don’t love to carry cash around with you. Instead, you can just carry your gift cards right on your phone that you take with you everywhere already. You don’t even have to worry about keeping track of the gift cards and the balances because your phone does all of that for you. There really isn’t a more convenient option when it comes to buying gift cards and gifts for yourself or others.

Check out eleven of the best restaurants in Bar Harbor, Maine that serve delicious lobster!

1. Thirsty Whale Tavern

Great seafood restaurant near Acadia National Park to pick up on-the-go, or to stop by and eat indoors!

📍 40 Cottage St | Bar Harbor | thirstywhaletavern.com‍

Thirsty Whale makes it to the top of my list of best places to get lobster around Bar Harbor for a couple of reasons. First of all is that they have a fantastic rating with their customers. The next reason is that the Thirsty Whale has a really well balanced menu. Whether you want a filling lunch or an incredible seafood dinner, the Thirsty Whale is going to be able to provide exactly what you are looking for. 

If you’re looking for a lobster roll, clam chowder, or another New England seafood classic, you’ll be able to find it at the Thirsty Whale! And if somebody in your party isn’t in the mood for lobster, or seafood in general, then don’t worry, they also feature a full lunch and dinner menu with plenty of non-seafood based options to choose from.

But more than anything, I think it speaks volumes about how great the Thirsty Whale is, that it is the highest rated seafood restaurant in Bar Harbor. Which is very impressive because Bar Harbor is perfectly located to have some of the freshest seafood you can get anywhere in the country. I mean it is right on the coastline really. So the Thirsty Whale being able to stand shoulders above the very high level of competition in the local seafood restaurant scene really says a lot about how great of an establishment the Thirsty Whale is. 

“Totally worth the wait. The service was excellent and the food was amazing. Will remain on our list of "go to's" in Bar Harbor.” - Yelp Review

2. Parsons Lobsters

A great small family-owned lobster joint in Bar Harbor where you can support locals while enjoying fresh lobster!

📍 64 Eagle Lake Rd | Bar Harbor | facebook.com/lobstahs

Parsons Lobster makes it to number two on my list of great lobster places in Bar Harbor over some of the restaurants that are a little more established for a few reasons. First of all, they have a four star rating with their customers. Which means that even though they are a smaller restaurant than some of the other places on the list, they are still attracting and pleasing a solid amount of customers. 

And on top of that, it’s not just that they do a good job, they are also a small friendly family owned business. As somebody who has worked for plenty of small business owners over the years, I’m always happy to give a shout out to another small business owner. After all, what makes an amazing meal more amazing than knowing the money spent on that meal went to support local businesses and local farmers. 

“Great fresh lobsters, and the friendliest people you'll ever meet. They let my kids pose with the lobsters, told them about the biology of lobsters, and even let us borrow a lobster pot so we could cook them over our campfire. I'm from Oklahoma but I'm pretty sure it's worth the drive out there to visit again.” - Yelp Review

3. West Street Cafe

Great lobster included in a balanced menu with tons of other New England-style dishes and sweet dessert!

📍 76 W St | Bar Harbor | weststreetcafe.com‍

West Street Cafe is an excellent cafe style restaurant you can find around Bar Harbor. So while you can expect to get some fantastic fresh lobster when you stop here, they also have a whole menu of fantastic other options. But no matter what you decide to go with for lunch or dinner be sure to try some of their blueberry pie. 

Positive review after positive review mentioned how out of the world their pie was so be sure to grab a slice to take home with you even if you don’t have room after all the delicious seafood. Which comes in a variety of different classic New England styles, crab cakes, clam chowder, lobster bisque, you name and the West Street Cafe can prepare it for you with ease.

“A very nice oasis of calm with views of the wharf.  The whole lobster is terrific! Went quite well with a Bloody Mary. What more is there to say?!” - Yelp Review 

4. The Barnacle

Pub-style food where you can find some of the best lobster in Bar Harbor!

📍 112 Main St | Bar Harbor | thebarnaclebarharbor.com‍

So The Barnacle isn’t your traditional sit down restaurant, but it isn’t exactly your typical pub either. Instead what you will find is a great hybrid between the two. The fact of the matter is, it’s kind of the nicest pub you could hope to find. It’s quaint and charming, but still has excellent service and wonderful food. 

While we know that this is a list of the places to get the best lobster in Bar Harbor, The Barnacle is famous not just for their amazing lobster options, but also because they apparently have out of this world oysters. I personally wouldn’t know because oysters aren’t really my cup of tea, but for those of you who do enjoy them, apparently The Barnacle has some of the best you can find anywhere.

More than anything, The Barnacle is going to be a great spot for you to stop if you are hoping for a cold beer and a hot meal. And honestly who doesn’t want that after spending a long day exploring one of our national forests. 

“Friendly bartender, Cosmo and friendly strangers :) It's a nice intimate bar, with locals and visitors like me just there to have a good time, good food. Food was delicious, wine, beer on tap.” - Yelp Review 

5. Bar Harbor Lobster Bakes

Best Lobster bakes in Bar Harbor that are unique to this restaurant and the state of Maine!

📍 10 Rte 3 | Bar Harbor | barharborlobsterbakes.com‍

Bar Harbor Lobster Bakes is going to feature all kinds of excellent seafood and lobster options, but they are obviously famous for their lobster bakes. But you really can’t go wrong with any of the options they offer at Bar Harbor Lobster Bakes. The only issue with this place is that it is so popular around the area that sometimes entire tour buses stop off for a meal. So just be sure to make sure they’ll have a table for you.

‍If you manage to get a table at a time when they aren’t crazy busy then you are going to be pleasantly surprised by the very friendly and attentive staff.

“The lobster roll was perfect, large pieces of fresh lobster with limited mayonnaise on a fresh roll. The blueberry pie with ice cream was delicious. Server efficient, friendly and helpful.  Could not have been better!” - Yelp Review 

6. Bar Harbor Lobster Company

A great place to go to when pairing lobster and rum together for a tasty meal!

📍 297 Main Street | Bar Harbor | bhlobster.com

If you are looking for a great lobster restaurant that really has it all then Bar Harbor Lobster Company is going to be just the spot for you. Of course they have all the fantastic lobster dishes you can expect. Everything from a lobster roll to lobster bisque is on the menu. On top of that, you can also expect a full dinner menu featuring plenty of BBQ. 

If you want something to compliment your meal, they also offer a full rum bar and there are plenty of craft beers on tap as well. So no matter who is in your dining party, I’m pretty sure they will be able to find something that works for them at Bar harbor Lobster Company. And that means that you will be able to enjoy your delicious lobster dinner without having to hear anybody complain about how they don’t like this or that because they will have plenty of options they do like to choose from. 

“Best lobster roll I've had!  Loaded with lots of fresh lobster that was cooked to perfection.  I'll be back whenever we're within driving distance.” - Yelp Review ‍

7. Geddy’s

A family-friendly restaurant serving pub grub, beer, and the best lobster in Bar Harbor!

📍 19 Main Street | Bar Harbor | geddys.com

There are many restaurants and bars in Bar Harbor, Maine, but there is nothing quite like Geddy’s. If you’re looking for a spot that sells seafood, including the best lobster in Bar Harbor, Geddy’s has what you’re looking for, especially if you want to go somewhere more family-friendly. Not only do they serve lobster, but they also have lobster rolls, American comfort food, and even an extensive list of beer to choose from.

New England seafood at Geddy’s in Bar Harbor, Maine has been rated as a #1 favorite among  many. In a lively and fun atmosphere, Geddy’s serves up some of the freshest lobster in Bar Harbor, Maine and much more, including clam chowder, fish and chips, seafood, ahi tuna tacos, ahi tuna poke, and you can even grab a piece of their signature blueberry pie. 

“If you are looking for a touristy spot to grab some good food this is the place! It was so fun and the food was great.” - Yelp Review

8. Stewman’s Lobster Pound

An oceanfront restaurant in Bar Harbor serving lobster, other seafood options, and cocktails too!

📍 35 W Street | Bar Harbor | stewmanlobsterpound.com

With so many options for food and drinks in Bar Harbor, getting something fresh from the ocean is the way to go. Many people who live in New England thoroughly enjoy fresh seafood, especially at Stewman’s Lobster Pound. This is a popular casual eatery that serves fresh seafood options, including lobster, and you can even pair it with one of their signature cocktails.

Stewman’s Lobster Pound provides a tourist-y experience because it sits right on the water in Bar Harbor, Maine, providing a beautiful view while enjoying your seafood dish, or even to sip on cocktails with loved ones. Some of their iconic dishes include the famous lobster roll, clam chowder, lobster bisque, lobster cobb salad, crab rolls, and even some fish and chips.

“This place was everything I'd hoped for our Maine lobster experience. The restaurant is on the water and the views are nice. Highly recommend checking this place out.” - Yelp Review

9. Frenchman Bay Lobster Rolls

Lobster rolls are a classic in Bar Harbor, Maine and  they serve some of the best in town at this spot!

📍 5 Main Street | Bar Harbor | thetravelinlobster.com

Sometimes all you’re craving is a lobster roll, and there’s no better place to get one than in Bar Harbor, Maine. Lobster rolls are a New England signature classic that is lobster meat served on a hot dog bun, with butter, lemon juice, and mayo sauce. We know that it sounds delicious, and luckily you can find some of the best at Frenchman Bay Lobster Rolls.

Whenever you go to Frenchman Bay Lobster Rolls, they offer quick service when you’re craving lobster rolls. They offer a spicier version of one, a plain one, one with coleslaw, a lobster BLT, and even a crab roll, plus soups and mac n’ cheese to pair with it for a quick and easy meal.

“The lobster is super delicious. The restaurant warmly provided picnic blankets to let customers sit on the grass, enjoying the beautiful scene with an amazing lobster roll!” - Yelp Review

10. Testa’s Bar & Grill

Seafood, steak, sandwiches, and cocktails that are perfect for a night out on the harbor!

📍 53 Main Street | Bar Harbor | testasbarharbor.com

When you’re craving the freshest seafood in Bar Harbor, Maine, there are plenty of places to go. Since Bar Harbor is located right by the ocean, there are many restaurants in the surrounding area that offer fresh seafood options, plus other delicious dishes, such as Testa’s Bar & Grill. This is a hotspot that offers the freshest fish, including lobster, and even other specialties, such as steak, sandwiches, and even cocktails to pair with your meal.

Testa’s Bar & Grill offers fresh and succulent seafood like lobster that can be made in many different ways. Not only do they offer classic lobster rolls, but also lobster tacos, coconut shrimp, freshly caught blackened fish tacos, seafood alfredo, fish and chips, and even some of the juiciest steaks you’ll ever try.

“What a great place to sit at the bar, have a cocktail and watch people go by. Tasty cocktails, and good food as well! I had the shrimp tacos and they are a huge serving of lightly fried shrimp, and all the toppings.” - Yelp Review

10. The Chart Room

Pasta, prime rib, and New England seafood are on the menu at this casual eatery in Bar Harbor!

📍 565 Eden Street | Bar Harbor | chartroombarharbor.com

There is nothing better than enjoying seafood that is freshly caught and cooked in Bar Harbor, Maine. With so many restaurants in the area that serve fresh seafood, it can be difficult to find the best spot in town to go to. The Chart Room is a great option and they are open seven days a week offering everything from seafood, prime rib, and pasta in a fun, fresh environment.

The Chart Room has been a staple in the Bar Harbor area for over thirty years and is a place for both the locals and tourists to go to. With perfectly prepared seafood and other food options such as lobster rolls, clam chowder, lobster stew, bang bang shrimp, crab cakes, macadamia crusted halibut, and even prime rib, this is the place to go and enjoy both indoor and outdoor seating, a cocktail, and some great food. 

“Amazing food. We ordered the Seafood Linguine and the Hanger Steak and they were both delicious. You can sit out on the pier which is a cool experience and you can watch the sunset too! Great experience!” - Yelp Review

Choose One of These Top 11 Restaurants in Bar Harbor, Maine for the Most Delicious Lobster

There you have it! All the best rated lobster restaurants you can find in Bar Harbor. Bar Harbor is right on the ocean so you can expect all the amazing seafood offerings that these fine dining establishments have to be of the freshest quality you can find. 

You are definitely in the right place for great seafood if you are in the Bar Harbor area. Whether you live in Bar Harbor, or are just there to visit one of our great national parks, you have plenty of excellent options to find fresh and tasty lobster. But if you didn’t find exactly what you were looking for on this ist, be sure to check out one of our other great articles on places to eat around the Bar Harbor area!