The 12 Best Italian Restaurants in Omaha That Will Make You Say “Mama Mia!”

Diving into the best Italian food is something a lot of people enjoy, so here are the twelve best restaurants to check out in Omaha, Nebraska!

Finding the best Italian Restaurant in Omaha is no easy task to accomplish. There are so many options when it comes to Italian food it is hard to say what is technically the “best.” There’s everything from authentic Northern Italian dishes to delicious and savory Mediterranean Italian dishes. 

It’s hard to say which restaurant is for sure the best Italian restaurant in Omaha because of this. I mean can a steak really be that much better than lobster ravioli or vice versa? It all depends on what you are in the mood for. 

In this article, we’re going to discuss:

  • The best Italian restaurants in Omaha
  • Where you can find these amazing restaurants
  • An insider look on what Yelp reviewers are saying

So in order to help narrow down your search though, we have taken the restaurants with the highest Yelp and TripAdvisor reviews and condensed them down into one accessible list with the top restaurants on it. This list includes the websites and addresses for all of the restaurants. So that way you can check out the menu and location before you head out. And it just so happens that every restaurant on this list also happens to accept GiftYa digital gift cards.

And just like with all the posts here on GiftYa we are compelled to remind you that a GiftYa is a digital gift card that can be sent within seconds right from your phone. These gift cards can be used at a variety of locations but are particularly popular for restaurants. 

This is especially true if you are out traveling and don’t love to carry cash around with you. Instead you can just carry your gift cards right on your phone that you take with you everywhere already. You don’t even have to worry about keeping track of the gift cards and the balances because your phone does all of that for you. There really isn’t a more convenient option when it comes to buying gift cards and gifts for yourself or others.

1. Mangia Italiana

18 years in business and locally owned and operated

Get a Mangia Italiana gift card

If you’re looking for something super delicious when it comes to Italian food, don’t miss out on Mangia Italiana. Image courtesy of Instagram

6516 Irvington Road | Irvington, West Omaha |

Mangia Italiana is known as being a proud member of the Omaha area. Being locally owned and operated for the past 18 years has made it a staple of the Omaha community. Since being established in 2003 the family owned restaurant has used cooking traditions that began four generations ago. When the great grandparents of the current owners came from the Old Country to live in Omaha’s very own little Italy.

Serving a wide variety of different menu items you’ll be sure to find something appetizing at Mangia Italiana. This includes a full range of Italian cuisine that includes pizza, pasta, chicken, seafood, sandwiches, and desserts. Covering all of the staples of Italian cuisine.

“Food is absolutely amazing! The large portions didn't stop me from finishing all of my food.” - Yelp Review 

Get a Mangia Italiana gift card

2. Avoli Osteria

Wine and simple food from Northern Italy

Get a Avoli Osteria gift card

Are you craving Northern Italian food? If you are, then make sure to check out Avoli Osteria! Image courtesy of Instagram.

5013 Underwood Avenue | Dundee |

Opened a little over 8 years ago, Avoli Osteria features food and wine from Northern Italy. This food is simple but served with an emphasis on pasta, grilled meats, and fish.

However you will find the interior of the restaurant to be anything but simple. With lavish chandeliers and ambient lighting you will be sure to find the upscale authentic Italian cuisine you are after when you visit Avoli Osteria in Omaha. You can even reserve a private room just by following their website.

“We have been a handful of times, and it's been nothing but perfect in each and every instance.” - Yelp Review 

Get an Avoli Osteria gift card

3. Spezia

An upscale yet casual Italian restaurant 

Get a Spezia gift card

Spezia is an incredible Italian restaurant with both an upscale and casual setting that you won’t want to miss out on. Image courtesy of Instagram

3125 S 72nd Street | Midtown |

Spezia has been serving Omaha for over six years with an upscale casual restaurant. The restaurant is located just north of I-80. And the menu at Spezia features italian steaks and seafood in a warm and comfortable dining environment. Not only does the menu offer a full selection of expertly prepared dishes, it also features plenty of beer, wine, and cocktails.

“We always make it a point to eat here every trip to Omaha.  Great service, great food, and wonderful ambiance.  ” - Yelp Review

Get a Spezia gift card

4. Nicola’s Italian Wine and Faire

One of the best Mediterranean Italian restaurants in Omaha

Get a Nicola’s Italian Wine and Faire gift card

Who doesn’t love a good glass of wine with their Italian food? Come get the best at Nicola’s Italian Wine and Faire! Image courtesy of Instagram

521 S 13th Street | Old Market, Downtown |

Nicola’s offers a full menu of both food, as well as wine and beer, curbside pickup and even delivery to some Omaha locations. It's hard to go wrong with Nicola’s menu but they are most known for their upscale Lobster Ravioli, Classic Carbonara, and their Mediterranean Lasagna.

This upscale menu is paired with an extensive wine list as well as a full bar and garden patio.

“I loved this place so much. The service was wonderful and the food came out hot and fast. ” - Yelp Review

Get a Nicola’s Italian Wine and Faire gift card

5. Orsi’s Italian Bakery and Pizzeria

Serving Omaha for over one hundred years

Get a Orsi’s Italian Bakery and Pizzeria gift card

If you are wanting to check out an Italian bakery and get some pizza too, then make sure to check out Orsi’s Italian Bakery and Pizzeria today! Image courtesy of Instagram.

621 Pacific Street | Little Italy |

Since the year 1919 Orsi’s Italian Bakery and Pizzeria has been the location for authentic Italian cheeses, breads, pasta, and meats. Having operated for over one hundred years you can be sure that Orsi’s food and service have stood the test of time. Generations of experience go into every dish that is served. And you can taste not only the experience but also the authenticity of the chef’s craft.

“This is going to be the pizza place we go out of our way to visit every time we're on this side of the country. Orsi's completely turned around an otherwise tiring day and we have plenty left to bring with us on the next leg of our journey. Thank you!!” - Yelp Review 

Get a Orsi’s Italian Bakery and Pizzeria gift card

6. Lo Sole Mio Ristorante Italiano

Features the third generation of the family to work at the business

Get a Lo Sole Mio Ristorante Italiano gift card

Are you interested in getting some tasty Italian food in Omaha? Make sure to check out Lo Sole Mio Ristorante Italiano today! Image courtesy of Instagram

3001 S 32nd Avenue  | South Omaha |

With only a three and a half star rating on Yelp, Lo Sole Mio comes in a bit further down on our list than the other restaurants you have seen. The restaurant has stood the trials of time though. Opening in 1992 it has been open for almost thirty years. 

The restaurant is family owned and operated and features the third generation of the family to work at the business. They serve quality homemade Italian food. This food is all prepared and served in their relaxing friendly environment. The husband and wife who run the restaurant have worked in food together for over 50 years!

“This has become our go-to restaurant for Italian. The food is good, prices are reasonable, and great ambience. ” - Yelp Review 

Get a Lo Sole Mio Ristorante Italiano gift card

7. Malara’s Italian Restaurant

An unforgettable Italian meal

Get a Malara’s Italian Restaurant gift card

Italian meals that will have you saying “mama mia!” is exactly what you’ll get at Malara’s Italian Restaurant! Image courtesy of Instagram

2123 Pierce Street | Omaha |

Marla’s states that they want to serve you and your family “an unforgettable Italian meal.” Featuring both dine in or carry out options they are sure to be able to provide an Italian meal for whatever your needs in Omaha are that night. 

One convenient thing at Marla’s is that their staff is multilingual and speaks English, Spanish, and Italian. So you can feel free to order in your native tongue if it makes you feel more comfortable. This gives the restaurant a true Italian and multicultural feel that you won’t find at the other Italian restaurants in Omaha

“Servers were friendly and attentive. Manager stopped by the table to make sure everything was great. Fresh warm rolls to start, always a winner with us.” - Yelp Review 

Get a Malara’s Italian Restaurant gift card

8. Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano

If you’re looking for something delicious when it comes to Italian, this is the place

Struggling to find the best Italian restaurant in Omaha, then you need to come and check out Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano! Image courtesy of Instagram.

13655 California Street | West Omaha |

Sometimes there is nothing better than some classic Italian flavors and so much more. If this sounds exactly what you’re looking for, then you need to stop what you’re doing and check out Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano in Omaha today!

Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano has a ton of incredible Italian dishes that you won’t want to miss out on, such as the butternut squash ravioli, lobster corn chowder, bruschetta, short rib ravioli, fettuccine, and so much more. Classic and new inventive Italian dishes are right up Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano’s alley, so make sure to try them out right away!

“Beautiful inside and out! Great wait service. And the food is amazing with of course a heaping portion of food.” - Yelp Review

9. Pasta Amore

Who doesn’t love pasta? If you’re a pasta fanatic, this is the place for you

There are a ton of amazing Italian restaurants in Omaha, Nebraska, but there is none quite like Pasta Amore! Image courtesy of Instagram.

11027 Prairie Brook Road | West Omaha |

West Omaha is home to a ton of amazing Italian restaurants that you won’t want to miss out on, especially Pasta Amore! Pasta Amore is home to some of the best and tastiest pastas that are around that come in a ton of different flavors, and they also serve other authentic Italian dishes too.

You won’t want to miss out on the bruschetta, bolognese, chicken piccata, carbonara, wedding soup, and other classic and authentic Italian dishes. All of the pasta is homemade, along with the bread, ricotta, and so much more. Come and check out Pasta Amore as soon as you can!

“Big servings and amazing service! Definitely a romantic spot hidden in Rockbrook. Would definitely go back to try more things on their menu!” - Yelp Review 

10. Vincenzo’s Ristorante

Homemade Italian classics is what you can’t miss out on in Omaha

There are a ton of amazing Italian dishes to try out in Omaha and we think that you need to go to Vincenzo’s Ristorante right away! Image courtesy of Instagram.

15701 Pacific Street | West Omaha |

If you’re still on the hunt for the best Italian restaurant in Omaha, Nebraska, then there is truly no place quite like Vincenzo’s Ristorante! Vincenzo’s Ristorante has a ton of homemade Italian options to choose from and they’re also locally owned, so you can further support small businesses!

At Vincenzo’s Ristorante, you need to try out the tortellini bianco pasta, caesar salad, shrimp scampi pasta, angel hair pasta, shrimp imbottito pasta, and so much more authentic flavors that you won’t want to miss out on. Come and check out Vincenzo’s Ristorante as soon as you can!

“Everything was prepared well, the service was speedy and our waitress was very attentive.  I highly recommend Vincenzo's for a great Italian meal.” - Yelp Review

11. Spaghetti Works

The perfect place for any spaghetti fan out in Omaha

Get a Spaghetti Works gift card

Trying to find the perfect Italian restaurant to go to in Omaha, Nebraska can be difficult, but you should check out Spaghetti Works ASAP! Image courtesy of Instagram.

502 S 11th Street | Old Market, Downtown | 

Sometimes indulging in some of the best Italian food from a family-friendly restaurant where the atmosphere is real casual is just what you need, so why not take a second to check out what there is to offer over at Spaghetti Works right away!

Spaghetti Works has some of the best Italian food that is in Omaha and at a great price as well. You may be wondering what is sold there and you can try out anything from the spicy marinara, spaghetti and meatballs, cajun chicken alfredo, bruschetta, penne, and so much more. Don’t miss out on what there is to offer over at Spaghetti Works!

“Delicious!! Wonderful service, fantastic salad bar, amazing Spaghetti, reasonable prices.” - Yelp Review

Get a Spaghetti Works gift card


Get some of the best wood-fired Neapolitan pizza in Omaha 

Whenever someone says Italian food, pizza is one of the first things that may pop in your mind, so make sure to check out DANTE right away! Image courtesy of Instagram.

16901 Wright Plaza | West Omaha |

Are you a huge fan of pizza and want to try only the best in Omaha, Nebraska? If this sounds like you, then you need to stop what you’re doing and try out DANTE right away! DANTE is known for their incredible wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas that come with many different kinds of toppings, crusts, and so much more.

Whenever you go to DANTE, you need to try out the margherita pizza, Plum Creek chicken, Amore Di Carne pizza, Giuseppe pizza, and a ton of other classic Neapolitan pizza options, along with tasty authentic Italian food you need to try out. Come and give DANTE a try as soon as you can right in Omaha!

“The food at Dante's. Incredible. The service at Dante's. Incredible. The consistency at Dante's. Incredible.” - Yelp Review 

No matter what kind of Italian cuisine you are craving, Omaha is sure to offer a solution that works for you. Featuring everything from Northern Italian cuisine to Mediterranean food, to a century old family shop with homemade pizzas, to an upscale dining experience, Omaha is sure to have the Italian dining experience you are looking for. 

There are even more options than appeared on our list as well but these are just a synthesis of the highest rated Italian restaurants in Omaha compiled into one easily accessible list.

And don’t forget that every restaurant that appeared on this list had the option of sending a digital GiftYa restaurant gift card. You can simply follow the links posted through this article in order to get a gift card for yourself or as a gift for a loved one who is visiting in Omaha, or maybe even one who lives there. 

No matter what scenario you find yourself in, a GiftYa digital gift card makes for the optimal way to eat out at restaurants. The no hassle digital cards are impossible to lose and can be sent within seconds. They even keep track of the balance for you.

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts

Food & Drink
11 Best Restaurants for Breakfast + Brunch in Boise

From Sizzling Bacon to Fluffy Pancakes, Here Are the Best Places to Fuel Up with Breakfast and Brunch in The Gem State

Food & Drink
12 Restaurants That Serve the Best Brunch in Portland

From Pastries Shops to Old School Diners, Local Joints to National Chains, Here are the Absolute Best Places for Breakfast and Brunch in Portland, Oregon