7 Old Restaurants in Salisbury, MD You Should Try for Something New Tonight

So you're looking for old restaurants in Salisbury Maryland huh? You probably searched for something like “Salisbury old restaurants” or “the best old restaurants in Salisbury” or maybe even “historic old restaurants in Salisbury.” 

Well don’t worry, you came to the right place. You didn’t really think Google would lead you askew or astray did you? Of course this is the place you are looking for! 

If you live in Salisbury, are just there for an afternoon, or have a friend or loved one who is there, this list will feature some of the best old restaurants in Salisbury for a lunch or dinner you can find. 

This list features some historic restaurants and some restaurants that come from long culinary traditions, but all of the restaurants featured here today were chosen because they are some of the best reviewed old restaurants in Salisbury. There is sure to be something on the list that piques your interest, or at least piques your appetite. 

And whenever you find what it is that you’re looking for, we provide links to every restaurant's website so you can decide what you want ahead of time. We’ll even let you know if one of the old restaurants in Salisbury accept our quality and convenient digital GiftYa gift cards.

What’s a GiftYa gift card, you might be wondering?

Virtual GiftYa Cards make the perfect gift for loved ones and for anybody who likes to explore or travel. Why?

First, these virtual gift cards can be sent and received within seconds. Usually with a special message inside with well wishes towards a loved one or special friend. The virtual gift cards are as easy to send as an email or a text message and can be purchased for nearly ten thousand different merchants and businesses. 

You can personalize the gift message, and send it directly to your recipient’s phone, all within seconds. GiftYa’ digital format provides not only a speedy delivery but also a convenient way to store and maintain different gift card balances. You don’t need to worry about having that particular gift card for that particular establishment on that particular day, as long as you have your phone, GiftYa cards are with you. Check out the list of top old restaurants in Salisbury Maryland below, including several that accept GiftYa! 

Now that we’re all on the same page, let’s get back to the main event: the best old restaurants Salisbury, MD has to offer!

Morgan’s Oyster House

Award-Winning Food in a Historic Old Building in Salisbury

100 E Main St | Salisbury | morgansoysterhouse.com

Like lots of towns, some of the buildings in Salisbury have been around for a while. The historic One East Plaza Building – formerly The Wicomico Hotel – was originally built in the 1920s and credited with revitalizing tourism and bringing economic prosperity to the town. Thanks to restoration efforts, the building’s legacy continues to live on as the home of businesses like Morgan’s Oyster House.

Sit outside and soak up views of beautiful and historic downtown Salisbury, or grab a seat inside for a show. With an open concept kitchen, guests can watch the culinary team in action.

The oysters are, of course, an excellent choice, but you can’t go wrong with Morgan’s other offerings. Locals love the crab cakes and lobster rolls.

“We chose Morgans to celebrate my son's college graduation and I was delighted from the moment I called to make a reservation. The staff were amazing from the very beginning until we walked out of the door. It was an absolutely amazing experience that featured amazing food. The crab dip appetizer and Fontina Bay biscuits were a great way to start our meal.” - Yelp Review 

Morgan’s Oyster House doesn’t offer GiftYa digital gift cards just yet, but check back soon because we are always adding old restaurants and attractions in Salisbury!

Sobo’s Wine Beerstro

Serving Up Southern Hospitality in Since 2006

1015 Eastern Shore Dr | Salisbury | .soboswinebeerstro.com 

Located just across the Wicomico River from Salisbury’s historic downtown, Sobo’s Wine Beerstro is creating a history of serving some of the best southern comfort food in the North one day at a time. The restaurant works closely with local farmers and fishermen to provide fresh, locally-sourced seasonal menu items that delight the taste buds. Pair with a drink from Sobo’s award-winning wine list, and you have a recipe for a grand old time.

Not sure what to order? Locals love the blackened rockfish, Nashville cauliflower, and classic chicken salad sandwich for lunch.

“A total gem in Salisbury, I was so happy to come here! The ambiance is warm and inviting and the wine selection is just perfect. I was with a group so was able to try an array of items after coming here two nights in a row (because yes, it was that good!). Everything on the plate was perfect cooked and tasted exactly as I expected from the menu description.” - Yelp Review

Sobo’s Wine Beerstro is one of the thousands of restaurants that accepts digital GiftYa gift cards but it is also among one of the highest rated old restaurants in Salisbury!

Fratelli’s Italian Restaurant

Authentic Italian Cuisine with Plenty of Seafood Flair

925 Snow Hill Rd | Holly Center | fratellissby.com

Just because it’s steeped in history doesn’t mean it has to be inaccessible. Fratelli’s Italian Restaurant brings a touch of casual elegance to the restaurant scene in Salisbury, where it has been serving up authentic Italian food for years. And the flavors Fratelli’s incorporates into their dishes have been around even longer, reaching back to the ancient villages of southern Europe.

Fratelli’s has been voted Best Restaurant on the Eastern Shore 10 years in a row, so they have quite a reputation for excellence in town. If you’re planning a weekend visit, consider calling ahead to avoid waiting for a highly coveted seat.

But what should you order once you’ve taken a seat at Fratelli’s? Consider picking a fan favorite from the menu, like their seafood alfredo or their award-winning crab cakes. If you aren’t feeling seafood, you can also chow down on juicy steak or homemade pasta dishes as well.

“Stopped here on a road trip for lunch. What an amazing decision. Best Chicken Alfredo I've ever had. You can definitely taste that their pasta is homemade. Awesome service and breadsticks/ salad. Considering driving the 3 and 1/2 hours back just to eat here again, one day.” - Yelp Review 

Fratelli’s Italian Restaurant doesn’t offer GiftYa digital gift cards just yet, but check back soon because we are always adding Italian restaurants and attractions in Salisbury!

Market Street Inn

Indulge in the Finer Things and the Wilder Things in Life All at Once at This Restaurant on the Water in Historic Downtown Salisbury

130 W Market St | Salisbury | marketstreetinnsalisbury.com 

Market Street Inn has been serving locals in historic downtown Salisbury since 1979, so they know a thing or two about bringing good food and good service to their eatery. Originally an open-air sandwich shop, Market Street Inn has evolved over the years into a bar and then a casual but upscale restaurant and pub.

Not convinced yet? If you prefer to pair your meals with a fine glass of wine, Market Street Inn should be at the top of your list. They’ve been recognized by national publications like Wine Spectator and Wine enthusiast magazine for the extent and quality of their wine selection. 

Plus, Market Street Inn takes being a part of the Salisbury community to another level by getting involved in community projects. They’ve donated thousands of dollars to support local charities like The Joseph House and United Way of the Lower Eastern Shore, among others.

“Absolutely amazing place with first class atmosphere on the river and amazing food. Rob has also started brunch on Sundays that is incredible.” - Yelp Review 

Right now you aren’t able to get a GiftYa digital gift card to Market Street Inn but check back because there’s more old restaurants and stores in Salisbury added all the time.

Kellyn’s Kafe

Delicious Donuts, Breakfast, and Lunch Options

748 E Main St | Salisbury | kellynskafe.com 

The name Kellyn’s Kafe has only been around since 2018, but the business’s history goes back way further than that. Originally The Polar Bear, this location began serving customers in 1948. In 2004, the DeVage family took over ownership and renamed the shop DeVage’s, before it was eventually renamed Kellyn’s Kafe after the new owner’s daughter in 2018.

Kellyn’s is your go-to destination for breakfast or lunch. With everything from premium grass-fed beef burgers to tasty cake donuts topped in homemade glaze, ice cream, milkshakes, and more, there’s truly something for everyone.

“This place has the best donuts in Salisbury! I refuse to go to any chain donut place in Salisbury anymore. Their donuts are made fresh daily and you can see them making them throughout the day. Highly recommend.” - Yelp Review 

Unfortunately Kellyn’s Kafe isn’t one of the old restaurants in Salisbury participating with GiftYa just yet, but check back soon cause they might be any day now.

The Irish Penny Pub & Grill

Chow Down on American Comfort Food with an Eastern Shore Twist

1014 S Salisbury Rd | Salisbury | theirishpennypub.com 

Located in historic downtown Salisbury, The Irish Penny Pub & Grill is known in the area for offering something a little different. If you’re looking for a place to take a bite out of traditional Irish cooking and wash it down with a cold Guinness, this is your spot. The Irish Penny & Pub even welcomes live music on some evenings, so guests can enjoy dinner and a show.

“Incredible food, fair pricing and something different for the Salisbury Area. Highly recommend” - Yelp Review 

Unfortunately The Irish Penny Pub & Grill isn’t one of the old restaurants in Salisbury participating with GiftYa just yet, but check back soon cause they might be any day now.

Sage Diner

Enjoy Breakfast or Lunch in this Old School Diner

917 S Salisbury Blvd | Salisbury | sagedinermd.com

If you’re looking for the classic American diner – where you can get good coffee and hot breakfast for a reasonable price – Sage Diner is your place. Located in historic downtown, Sage Diner is an old school establishment. Pile your plate with eggs and pancakes, or sample some of their soups and sandwiches. Either way, you’re sure to leave Sage Diner satisfied. 

“Amazing staff, amazing food! Our waiter always has the kindest smile on his face and treats us exceptionally. My friends and I love to come in after a late night and enjoy a wonderful breakfast. The pies are also to die for- recommend the coconut cream.” - Yelp Review 

You can’t get a digital GiftYa gift card to Sage Diner at the moment but be sure to check back soon as new old restaurants and locations in Salisbury are added all the time!

That’s it for old restaurants in Salisbury, MD.

There you have it! All the best rated old restaurants you can find in Salisbury. Salisbury is a major hub of business and commerce so it isn’t easy to narrow down the list of great old restaurants to only what can fit in this post. But just from what we gathered for you here today you’ll be sure to find a location that's convenient for you with plenty of excellent options. 

And remember, if you or someone you love is out in Salisbury, we marked off which old restaurants accept convenient GiftYa digital gift cards. And you can use them at any of the locations we indicated on this list today. But even if you choose an old restaurant that doesn’t accept GiftYa, you’ll be sure to find plenty of tasty food. Salisbury and GiftYa definitely have something to offer.