7 Italian Restaurants in Salisbury, MD That Will Transport You Right to Nona’s Kitchen

Whether You’re Craving Pizza, Pasta, or Your Favorite Italian Dessert (Gelato, Anyone?) Salisbury, MD Has Plenty of Options

So you are looking for Italian restaurants in Salisbury huh? Probably searched for something like “Italian restaurants in Salisbury, MD” or “best Italian food in Salisbury,” right? 

What’s that? How did I know that? Well I mean this is on your phone or computer so this article will only show up for so many Italian restaurants that you searched in Google so I know it had to be something like that. Either that, or you got here from another GiftYa post or article in which case thank you for reading two today! 

Well today, just like everyday, we have exactly what you are looking for. This is a list of the best Italian restaurants in Salisbury and where you can find them. We also include links anytime one of these restaurants accept our super convenient virtual gift cards!

What’s that about virtual gift cards?

Yep, virtual gift cards! Just like with all the posts here on GiftYa we are compelled to remind you that a GiftYa is a digital gift card that can be sent within seconds right from your phone. 

These gift cards can be used at a variety of locations, but they are particularly popular for restaurants. This is especially true if you are out traveling and don’t love to carry cash around with you. 

Instead you can just carry your gift cards right on your phone that you take with you everywhere already. You don’t even have to worry about keeping track of the gift cards and the balances because your phone does all of that for you! There really isn’t a more convenient option when it comes to buying gift cards and gifts for yourself or others.

But that’s not what you came here to find now, is it? Since we’re all on the same page, it’s time to get back to our main event: the Italian restaurants in Salisbury, MD you definitely don’t want to miss.

Fratelli’s Italian Restaurant

Pizza, Pasta, and All Your Other Favorite Italian Fare

925 Snow Hill Rd | Holly Center | fratellissby.com

If you’re looking for Italian food that’s *chefs kiss* in Salisbury, Fratelli’s Italian restaurant should be your first stop. This award-winning restaurant has been voted Best Crab Cakes in Salisbury, as well as racking up awards for Best Italian Restaurant and Best Pasta as well. 

The decorations will transport you directly to Italy, with beautiful arches and wrought iron accents setting the ambiance. You may want to call ahead if you’re planning to stop in on a busy night of the week – with a reputation like the one Fratelli’s has, wait times can get lengthy on the weekends.

Once you’re seated, make sure you try out a couple of fan favorite menu items like the award-winning crab cakes, or other seafood options like seafood alfredo or stuffed shrimp. For those who prefer turf to surf, there are also plenty of steak and meat options available as well.

“Love Fratelli's. Always have such a wonderful meal. Portion sizes are huge, enough for lunch the following day. Best crab cakes and delicious crab toast oh and the stuffed shrimp are amazing! My husband gets chicken piccata every time - his favorite.” - Yelp Review 

Fratelli’s Italian Restaurant doesn’t offer GiftYa digital gift cards just yet, but check back soon because we are always adding Italian restaurants and attractions in Salisbury!

Cafe Italiano

Friendly Service and Flavorful Food Have Earned Cafe Italian a Reputation as One of the Best Restaurants in Town

701 E Naylor Rd | Salisbury | cafeitalianoofsalisbury.com

When you think of Italian restaurants, what comes to mind? If you’re thinking good food, good wine, and good people, then Cafe Italiano is the perfect place for you to get your Italian food fix in Salisbury. They’ve got all of your favorites – from cheese ravioli to spinach rolls to sandwiches on fresh Italian bread. 

With large servings and small price tags, you can eat your fill of Italian fare without breaking the bank. Don’t forget to save room for dessert – the cheesecake is phenomenal.

“A  hidden gem!  Yeah I was hungry, but the food tasted soooo good and they gave generous portions.  Looking forward to eating leftovers tomorrow.” - Yelp Review

You can’t get a digital GiftYa gift card to BLANK at the moment but be sure to check back soon as new Italian restaurants and locations in Salisbury are added all the time!

MayaBella’s Cafe and Pizzeria

Hand-Tossed Pizza in Salisbury’s Historic Downtown District

212 W Main St | Salisbury | mayabellas.com

People have strong pizza preferences, but MayaBella’s Cafe has a reputation for pleasing even the pickiest crowds. Since 2013, this local restaurant has been making a name for itself as one of the best in the business at serving up that old Italian classic: pizza. 

Custom order your own New York style pizza, or order one of the specialties pies on the menu like their BBQ pork pizza or the Hawaiian. No matter which way you decide to go, you won’t be disappointed.

“Great pizza joint! A little confusing to find, but I was with a local who knew what she was doing :) 

I was in town for work and we went here for lunch. Decently priced, good portions, and the pizza was so delicious. Being from the NJ/NY area, I'm definitely a snob and very picky about my pizza, so happy today this place passed my test!” - Yelp Review 

Unfortunately this isn’t one of the Italian restaurants in Salisbury participating with GiftYa just yet, but check back soon cause they might be any day now.

Pat’s Pizza and Pasta

Enjoy Top-Notch Italian Flavors in This Casual Pizzeria

1151 S Salisbury Blvd | Salisbury University | patspizzapasta.com

If you’re looking for casual Italian bites – we’re talking pizza, pasta, hoagies, and more – Pat’s Pizza and Pasta is the place to be. You don’t have to dress up for a visit to Pat’s. In fact, we’d even recommend giving yourself a little extra room in the waistband when you get dressed for your visit because you’ll want to eat until you burst.

Locals love the chicken cheesesteak sandwiches, stuffed steak pizza, and the cheesesteak pizza. There are lots of other options available, but fans of Pat’s think the steak is a cut above the rest.

“I am a Pat's regular now! My first meal here and most recent one was the chipotle chicken sandwich. This sandwich HITS. They got flavorful bacon with tender juicy chicken inside of rustic ciabatta buns smeared with beautiful chipotle sauce. Their waffle fries on the side shmack too!” - Yelp Review 

Right now you aren’t able to get a GiftYa digital gift card, but check back because there’s more Italian restaurants and stores in Salisbury added all the time.

G’latto Homemade Italian Creamery

Italian Dessert with Big Quality for a Small Price

Walk right up to the window for a sweet frozen treat. Image courtesy of Yelp.

1201-1227 Hwy 350 | Salisbury 

We couldn’t make a list of the best Italian restaurants in Salisbury without taking some time to talk about the delicious Italian dessert options over at G’latto Homemade Italian Creamery. Order your favorite frozen dessert, whether that’s gelato or a refreshing dairy-free sorbetto.

“I am allergic to milk and LOVE their dairy free sorbettos. It's really hard to find stuff like that. Their sorbettos are made fresh and are extremely creamy and high quality. I love the price too.” - Yelp Review 

There aren’t GiftYa digital gift cards available for as of the date of this writing, but there might be now! Be sure to check GiftYa itself for all the gift cards available for Italian restaurants in Salisbury.

Caesar’s Pizza Palace Restaurant

Family Owned and Operated Pizza Place with a Casual Atmosphere and Free Wifi for Guests

12302 Somerset Ave | Princess Anne | caesarspizzapalace.com 

In 2010, Caesar’s Pizza Palace Restaurant was just a dream shared by brothers-in-law John Dimarhos and Mike Halkias. Sure, there were other Italian restaurants in town, but did any of them really bring something unique to the table? And so Caesar’s Pizza Palace Restaurant was born, designed to give guests delicious food at affordable prices that would make it the perfect spot for working lunches, date nights, or even family dinner. 

Don’t be fooled by the name – while Caesar’s does serve some delicious pizza, it is far from the only thing on the restaurant’s menu. Made fresh every day, you can order anything from subs and strombolis to flounder filets and chicken parmesan. 

“Nice Italian ambience. Ordered  Supreme pizza.  Vegetables were hand-cut and fresh.  The thing I found most unusual was that the vegetables,  the meat,  the cheese,  and the sauce were spread all the way to the crust.  No complaints.” - Yelp Review 

As always we’re busy adding attractions and Italian restaurants in Salisbury to GiftYa all the time but you can’t get one here just yet. Check back soon.

Olive Garden

Take a Tour of Italy with Italian Favorites from All Over the Country Served Up on Your Dinner Table

2316 N Salisbury Blvd | Salisbury | .olivegarden.com

For many people, Italian food is comfort food. Whether they grew up swiping ingredients from the cutting board in Nona’s kitchen or they just love a plate piled high with flavorful, cheesy goodness, people have a soft spot for Italian cuisine. If none of the local Italian Restaurants on this list stuck out to you, consider going with a tried and true favorite like Olive Garden.

Between endless breadsticks and big plates like the pasta with five cheese marinara or the chicken and shrimp carbonara, you’re sure to leave satisfied.

“Never ever had a bad meal here.  Wait staff is wonderful!!!! Hostesses always make you feel welcome and seem genuinely glad to see you!  The food is always good.  Salad is great!  Breadsticks are so good - especially when they have just come out of the oven.  And their current deal buy one take one home is wonderful.  I love this place.” - Yelp Review 

Olive Garden is one of the thousands of restaurants that accepts digital GiftYa gift cards but it is also among one of the highest rated Italian restaurants in Salisbury!

That’s a wrap on Italian restaurants in Salisbury, MD.

There you have it! All the best rated Italian restaurants you can find in Salisbury. Salisbury is a major hub of business and commerce so it isn’t easy to narrow down the list of great Italian restaurants to only what can fit in this post. But just from what we gathered for you here today you’ll be sure to find a location that's convenient for you with plenty of excellent options. 

And remember, if you or someone you love is out in Salisbury, we marked off which Italian restaurants accept convenient GiftYa digital gift cards. And you can use them at any of the locations we indicated on this list today. But even if you choose an Italian restaurant that doesn’t accept GiftYa, you’ll be sure to find authentic Italian food. Salisbury and GiftYa definitely have something to offer.

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts