Just like there are some delicious Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh, there are also some amazing places to stock up on your favorite Italian groceries as well!
Lots of people in Pittsburgh can claim to come from Italian descent, and this type of food is very popular across the city. Many people want to recreate some of the fantastic meals they get out at Italian restaurants at home-- and need access to some authentic, quality ingredients. Italian marketplaces are the best options for you to pick up hard to find ingredients-- as well as ingredients that are made in the correct Italian way.
We’ve put together this list of Italian marketplaces in the Pittsburgh area-- where you can stock up on all your Italian favorites-- and even take home some freshly made dishes as well!
If you know someone that likes to cook Italian, get them a GiftYa electronic gift card to any of the places on the list below. They’re accepted at all these places-- as well as many other marketplaces throughout the Pittsburgh area. That way they can pick up the ingredients for an amazing Italian dinner!
2012 Penn Ave.
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Pennsylvania Macaroni Co. is a favorite stop for Pittsburghers looking for Italian speciality ingredients-- as well as some amazing pre-made food to take home. They offer all kinds of fresh meats, cheeses, breads, and desserts-- you’ll want to stock up on as much as you can!
Located in the Strip District, this shop has been selling Italian favorites since 1902. Make sure you sign up for their cheese and meat of the month club-- it’s a great way to sample their new food items!
“Awesome selection of goods! Amazing cheese and meats selection! The Italian goods and ingredients available are really great! Fair prices and good service.” -Yelp Review
4711 Liberty Ave.
Pittsburgh, PA 15224
Donatelli’s Italian Food Center is located in the Bloomfield neighborhood of Pittsburgh-- and is considered part of the city’s “Little Italy.” This family owned store is on its third generation of owners-- and they show no signs of letting up. In fact the store is growing to serve more people in the Pittsburgh area with delicious Italian specialties.
They’re fully stocked in all your favorite Italian meats, cheese, pastas, sauces, and dessert items. Whether you need to pick up a quick dinner on the go-- or are planning the food for a party-- this place has all your bases covered.
“Love this place for Italian staples like good quality anchovies, canned tomatoes, just about any cheese or pasta you could need... Of course, they have an olive bar.... And Boar's Head deli items!” -Yelp Review
3454 Bates St.
Pittsburgh, PA 15213
Merante Groceria is that quintessential Italian marketplace on the corner. They’ve been doing business in Oakland since the 1950s-- and have enjoyed bringing their Italian traditions to the people of Pittsburgh. Their store is stocked with some amazing produce, fresh bread, Italian pastas, sauces, oils, vinegars and much more.
This family run grocery store also serves up fresh deli sandwiches-- so the next time you’re in the mood for an Italian hoagie-- make sure you stop by and visit this place!
“I've been doing the majority of my grocery shopping at Groceria Merante for the entire time that I've lived in Oakland and I wouldn't want it any other way!” -Yelp Review
1901 Penn Ave.
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Sunseri Co. is another Italian market located in the heart of the Strip District. This place is a family run business that strives to give fresh Italian meats, cheeses, produce, and bread to the people of Pittsburgh.
This market is also famous for their Italian deli-- with it’s amazing selection of Italian cheeses-- as well as cheeses from other parts of Europe. It’s hard to find such a selection of imported cheeses, but Senseri Co. makes it a point to keep them stocked in their store.
“This little store also has great quality ingredients for making Italian food right at home. Homemade soups, sandwiches, and all kinds of goodness to be found here! Flavortown!” -Yelp Review
Aspinwall and various
605 Freeport Rd.
Pittsburgh, PA 15215
Labriola’s Italian Market has a couple of locations across Pittsburgh-- including Aspinwall, Monroeville, and Warrendale. Over the past 80 years, they have tried to bring the freshest Italian ingredients to Pittsburgh-- and offer some amazingly friendly customer service in the process. In addition to staples such as sauces, pasta, bread, and oils, this store also has fresh and hot items ready for purchase.
Stop in and try their eggplant parmesan, lasagne, wedding soup, or meatballs-- all made fresh daily!
“A must stop pretty much everytime I'm food shopping in Monroeville. A nice smaller store that carries specialty Italian goodies.” -Yelp Review
6390 US Rte. 30
Jeanette, PA 15644
DeLallo Italian Marketplace is just a short drive from Pittsburgh, and located in Jeannette in Westmoreland County. Since the 1950s, this family owned store has strived to share their passion for Italian food and Italian cooking with the people of Western Pennsylvania. Their products are found all over other grocery stores in the Pittsburgh area-- and is proof of the quality of their products.
In addition to an amazing selection of meat, fish, produce, and cheese, make sure you check out their handcrafted gift baskets full of all your favorite Italian goodies!
“Top notch Italian marketplace. I'd come here every day if I lived out here. Fresh bread and pastries baked on the premises. The freshest vegetables and fruits and olives!” -Yelp Review
1408 Potomac Ave.
Pittsburgh, PA 15216
Rocchio’s Italian Deli should definitely be on your list to try-- whether you’re looking for speciality bread or just need a fantastic homemade sandwich. This place stocks all your Italian favorites like sauces, olives, pasta, Mancini bread, and cheeses. Perhaps they’re better known for their famous meatball hoagie-- with a recipe that has been passed down for generations.
They also offer gelato, coffees, honey, salt and hand poured candles from Nat and Day-- so make sure you stop in and check them out!
“Delicious homemade pasta Fagoilo! Tasty Rocchio's Italian sandwich. Will have to return & try the homemade meatballs.” -Yelp Review
1734 Penn Ave.
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
If you’re looking for the premier place in Pittsburgh to pick up some amazing meat products, consider checking out Parma Sausage Co. This Italian marketplace is located in the Strip District-- and is just down the street from the other Italian grocery stores in the area.
This market specializes in using the finest pork and spices to handcraft their sausages. It’s a time honored tradition, and the family uses the same recipe that their grandfather used in Italy. Stop in and sample their antipasto or prosciutto-- you won’t be disappointed!
“This is a cute little shop in the strip district. The shop itself is extremely clean. The staff were helpful and knowledgeable. They make all meats in house.” -Yelp Review
No matter what Italian marketplace you decide to check out, you’re guaranteed to find some authentic, delicious ingredients to make a wonderful meal. Consider stopping by any of these markets the next time you’re craving home cooked Italian! What’s your favorite Pittsburgh Italian market? Let us know in the comments!