New York City's Hidden Gemstone Destinations: Top 10 Places to Explore

Picture a world where dazzling colors come alive, brilliance meets grace, and where gemstones hold the power to captivate your heart. You are now transfixed on one particular design flashing right in front of your eyes, and your heart races when you touch it. Feels surreal, right?

New York City boasts a plethora of places that can satiate your desire for exclusive and eclectic gemstones and jewelry. Within this bustling metropolis lies a treasure trove of gemstone delights, where vibrant colors, exquisite craftsmanship, and timeless elegance converge. 

Are you ready to embark on a captivating journey through the gemstone world of the Big Apple?

In this blog post, we will unveil the top 10 places in NYC to buy gemstones, each offering a unique and enchanting experience. From prestigious jewelry houses to hidden boutiques to online stores, we will guide you through a curated selection of destinations that showcase the city's gemstone splendor.

1. Tiffany & Co. - A Shimmering Legacy

Established by Charles Lewis Tiffany in 1837, Tiffany and Co. are now celebrated globally as a distinguished luxury brand for its exquisite jewelry, pioneering designs, and superior craftsmanship. It was one of the pioneer companies in the US to introduce gemstones, earning the title of "The Diamond Kings".

The company stands tall as a beacon of luxury and elegance. From the iconic Tiffany Setting engagement rings to their stunning gemstone jewelry, this legendary store offers an unrivaled selection for you to choose from. 

Explore their collection of diamonds, sapphires, and emeralds, and let the sparkle of Tiffany & Co. ignite your passion for gemstones.

2. Aaron Faber Gallery - Where Art Meets Gemstones

Located in the heart of Manhattan, the Aaron Faber Gallery honors the artistry of jewelry and watchmaking with its vast array of 20th and 21st-century eclectic jewelry and beautiful timepieces.

​​The gallery takes pride in showcasing the creations of more than 50 renowned and up-and-coming designers, with exclusive exhibitions spotlighting the jewelry world, collectors, artists, and aficionados.

From contemporary masterpieces to avant-garde creations, this unique gallery showcases a curated selection of gemstone jewelry created by visionary designers. 

3. Doyle & Doyle - Unveiling the Past

Your odyssey in the world of vintage and antique gemstone jewelry is incomplete without a visit to Doyle & Doyle. Founded by sisters Elizabeth and Irene Pamela Doyle, this boutique in the historic area of Manhattan embraces the rich history and timeless allure of antique treasures.

Entering Doyle & Doyle is like entering a museum of gemstone history. Their collection spans various eras, including Georgian, Victorian, Edwardian, Art Nouveau, and Art Deco, allowing visitors, like you, to explore the evolution of gemstone jewelry throughout the ages.

What sets Doyle & Doyle apart is their commitment to sourcing only the finest examples of antique gemstone jewelry. They meticulously select pieces based on their condition, rarity, and exceptional design, ensuring that visitors to the boutique can acquire unique and high-quality treasures that reflect the charm and character of the past.

4. Leibish - A Gemstone Paradise at Your Fingertips

Dive into the vibrant gemstone world presented by Leibish, the only exclusive online store on our list. Founded by Leibish Polnauer in 1979, the company brings a plethora of gemstone delights to your fingertips, offering a convenient and exciting shopping experience. 

As a renowned online gemstone retailer, Leibish is synonymous with exquisite colored gemstones. From vivid yellow diamonds to mesmerizing pink sapphires and captivating blue topazes, their collection is a true feast for the eyes.

With their online platform, you have the convenience of browsing their extensive collection, be it sapphires, garnets, or rubies, from the comfort of your home. The detailed product descriptions and high-resolution images at Leibish’s blog allow you to explore each gemstone up close, making an informed decision. 

The enterprise’s dedication to customer satisfaction is reflected in its exceptional customer service, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable shopping experience.

5. Greenwich St. Jewelers - Curated Excellence

Greenwich St. Jewelers is a destination where curated excellence meets gemstone allure. With a collection from established and emerging designers, their gemstone jewelry offerings are nothing short of extraordinary. 

Set up in 1976 by Carl and Milly Gandia, this family-owned boutique in New York City takes pride in its commitment to exclusivity and environmentalism. This can be the perfect place for you to individual style and reflects your inner radiance. 

From striking colored gemstone rings to elegant necklaces and bracelets, Greenwich St. Jewelers showcases an array of gemstone treasures that are sure to leave you in awe.

6. Aaron Basha - Playful Elegance

Prepare to be enchanted by the whimsical gemstone creations at Aaron Basha. Known for its iconic baby shoe charms, this boutique offers an imaginative and playful approach to gemstone jewelry. 

This renowned 4th generation business has become renowned for its "magical treasures", designed to bring joy to those with a childlike spirit. Their creations, which feature themes of love, energy, and youthfulness, have attracted a devoted following of customers from around the world, as well as recognition from high-profile clients and international royalty.

Explore their collection of vibrant gemstones, including dazzling diamonds, precious rubies, and captivating emeralds. From charm bracelets to statement rings, Aaron Basha embraces the joy and beauty of gemstones, adding a touch of elegance and individuality to every piece.

7. Kwiat - Diamonds, Gemstones, and Beyond

When it comes to diamonds, one name stands out among the rest in New York City - Kwiat. With a legacy dating back to 1907, this esteemed jewelry house has earned a reputation for its exceptional craftsmanship and breathtaking diamond creations.

Located in the heart of Manhattan, Kwiat also offers a truly immersive experience for those seeking the brilliance and beauty of gemstones. From vibrant sapphires in a spectrum of captivating hues to richly colored rubies and emeralds, their gemstone collection is a testament to the allure and diversity of colored gemstones.

From engagement rings that symbolize eternal love to diamond necklaces that 

make a statement, Kwiat’s designs are timeless, elegant, and crafted to perfection.

8. London Jewelers - A Legacy of Opulence

Founded in 1926, London Jewelers has been a trusted name in the world of fine jewelry for over 90 years, and their gemstone collection is a testament to their enduring legacy. Step into their luxurious store and immerse yourself in a world of opulence. 

From exquisite diamond necklaces to timepieces to show-stopping colored gemstone rings, London Jewelers offers an unparalleled selection. Discover gemstone treasures that embody elegance, sophistication, and timeless beauty.

9. Stephen Russell - Antique Splendor

For those with a penchant for antique gemstones, Stephen Russell is a must-visit destination. Specializing in antique and estate jewelry, this boutique showcases rare and exceptional gemstone pieces from various eras. 

Each jewel is meticulously selected for its beauty, historical significance, and exceptional craftsmanship. Experience the allure of bygone times as you admire their collection of antique gemstone rings, necklaces, and earrings. 

Stephen Russell is a treasure trove for connoisseurs of gemstone artistry.

10. Moon River Chattel - Bohemian Gemstone Delights

Escape into the bohemian world of Moon River Chattel, where gemstones and rustic charm collide. 

Located in Brooklyn, this charming boutique combines vintage treasures, handmade crafts, and gemstone delights to create a truly enchanting atmosphere. This eclectic store offers a unique selection of gemstone jewelry that reflects a free-spirited and unconventional aesthetic. 

Their collection features an eclectic mix of gemstone jewelry, from dainty rings adorned with ethereal opals to statement necklaces showcasing vibrant turquoise and amethyst. Each piece tells a story, embodying the free-spirited nature of bohemian aesthetics.

Let their unique collection transport you to a world of self-expression, where gemstones become the embodiment of your individuality and style.


New York City is a gemstone enthusiast's dream come true. From prestigious jewelry houses like Tiffany & Co. to hidden boutiques like Moon River Chattel, this captivating city offers a diverse range of gemstone destinations, each with its own charm and allure. 

Uncover the past, admire nature's brilliance, and immerse yourself in the kaleidoscope of colors. Whether you're searching for a timeless diamond piece or a unique-colored gemstone treasure, NYC has it all. So, embrace the sparkle and explore the options mentioned in the article for a truly unforgettable journey of gemstone discovery.

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts

Food & Drink
11 Best Restaurants for Breakfast + Brunch in Boise

From Sizzling Bacon to Fluffy Pancakes, Here Are the Best Places to Fuel Up with Breakfast and Brunch in The Gem State

Food & Drink
12 Restaurants That Serve the Best Brunch in Portland

From Pastries Shops to Old School Diners, Local Joints to National Chains, Here are the Absolute Best Places for Breakfast and Brunch in Portland, Oregon