Yup, That’s Right! We’re Searching for the Best Bagels in NYC!

There’s a couple “food” related things you first think about when we mention the name: New York City. Number one is pizza. There’s a lot of debate that New York is the place where you find the best pizza in the country, with many places advertising for $1 slices, you’ll have your fair share of bistros to pick from. The second food that pops into your head is bagels. Bagels are a staple in the city and there are so many places you can find all kinds of bagels so the list can get long fast. That’s why we’re here to find the best bagels in NYC for you so you don’t have to look too far. We’ve taken a deep dive into What To Do in NYC for a Day before so we have our work laid out ahead of us for the best bagels in NYC. 

But before we indulge in too much cream cheese and carbs, we should talk about GiftYa. GiftYa is an online distributor for thousands of eGift cards to restaurants, famous retailers, department stores, local businesses, online subscription services and shops, spas, hotels, airlines, and more. You can surprise a friend or loved one with a gift card whenever you feel like instantly thanks to GiftYa’s fast delivery system. All you have to do is go onto the website, pick a card they might like, choose an amount up to $250, customize it by adding a picture, video, and message, then decide whether you want to send it via text or email.

1. Broad Nosh Bagels Deli & Catering 42nd Street

Get the freshest, most delicious bagels for your morning or afternoon commute!

📍 587 9th Ave | New York | broadnoshonline.com

We’re starting out with arguably the best of the best bagels in NYC with Broad Nosh Bagels. With an impressive 4.9/5 stars on Google Reviews and a 4.3/5 on Yelp, they have made quite the mark on the culinary culture of the city. 

What makes them stand out flavor wise is that pretty much everything is made in-house, the hand roll their dough everyday and have their very own house made cream cheese so everything you try is made fresh as can be. 

New Yorkers love their Scallion Cream Cheese on Everything Bagel, the Bacon Egg & Cheese, and the Classic Nova Sandwich which features their amazing smoked salmon. Be prepared to wait as they are a popular spot but don’t you worry- it really is worth it.

“I had been craving a salted bagel with lox, dill, cucumber... and Broad Nosh did not disappoint!!! I actually couldn't wait to get back to my hotel, so yes, I did the unimaginable and walked and ate half of it. I could not wait! Amazing!” -Yelp Review

2. Between the Bagel NY

A gourmet bagel shop/bistro that offers unique twists on classics!

📍 31-13 30th Ave. | Astoria | instagram.com/betweenthebagelny

Between the Bagel NY is a relatively new bagel joint (it opened just before the pandemic started in 2020) but has built up quite the reputation over the last five years. With hundreds of 5 star reviews making their score on Google and Yelp 4.8/5- you can expect some quality service and quality bagels to boot. 

Their diverse menu makes it so everyone and everyone can get a bagel to match their unique tastes. They are hand-rolled and boiled to perfection so every bite feels like the first. They have a selection of bagels to choose from where you can pick and choose what fillings best fits your cravings along with other sandwiches, breakfast favorites, and pastries.

“Love this place! They don't take themselves seriously and joke around. But the food is no joke. Great bagels and try the specialty sandwiches. It is well worth a try. A lot more that a social media sensation.” -Yelp Review

3. Nala’s Bagel and Brunch

The best vibes can be found where the best bagels in NYC are: Nala’s!

📍 63 Reade St | New York | nalasbagelandbrunch.com

In the very beating heart of NYC you will find Nala’s Bagel and Brunch where everyone can come and grab a bite to eat while they take in the city itself. It opened in late 2024 and has already picked up hundreds of great reviews bringing it to a whopping 4.9/5 stars on Google. And with their success so far a second location is in the works. Nala’s isn’t just a bagel shop, although that’s what they pride themselves on the most, they also serve snacks, boards, and toast! If you’re looking to try some fresh and healthy breakfast foods then you’ll love coming to Nala’s.

“My husband & I stopped by before visiting the Brooklyn bridge & everything was AMAZING from the time we walked in till we left!!! Staff is so nice plus food & coffee was delicious! Very generous on portions & great prices. Will definitely return next time we’re in town!” -Google Review

4. Bagel Shop

Craving bagels? Go to the Bagel Shop! An apt name for a sensational spot!

📍 659 3rd Ave | New York | bagelshopnyc.com

The Bagel Shop which, yes, that is actually their restaurant’s name, is a place many come from far and wide to eat their delicious bagels. An apt name for a place serving some of the best bagels in NYC as they have thousands of five star reviews bringing their rating up to an impressive 4.7/5 stars on Google and 4.2/5 on Yelp. 

What we think makes them special compared to other bagel shops is their vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. It can be hard for people with other dietary needs to find something that they can eat and is delicious but The Bagel Shop does that for them. You can find your pick of sweet or savory bagels here with the likes of Jalapeno Cream Cheese and S’Mores Cream Cheese. They also serve lots of breakfast and lunch sandwiches, salads, muffins, scones, and more. You definitely won’t go hungry here!

“It's hard to stand out with so many bagel places in NYC, but this place definitely does. This is our favorite place to get bagel sandwiches whenever we have out of town guests. The southern fry is our go to! Nothing can top it.” -Yelp Review

5. Bagels & Schmear

Sandwiches, wraps, baked goods, pastries, bagels, and more await you!

📍 116 E 28th St | New York |bagelsandschmear.com

Since the beginning of this new century in 2000, Bagels & Schmear have been cooking up- or we should say, boiling up, some of the greatest bagels in the city. You won’t need to look too far here for a good bite to eat because not only do they serve their bagels fresh everyday but they also have a wide menu variety of wraps, sandwiches, breakfast plates, pancakes, french toast, bakery and grilled favorites, and more. 

Of course bagels are their speciality but their other menu options will leave you coming back to try more than that. They have a 4.6/5 star rating on Google and a 4.1/5 on Yelp- so plenty of good reviews to back up their popularity.

“Solid bagel spot! They run a really efficient operation, so the line moves fast even if it's long. Wide variety of bagels as well as other items like coffee, smoothies, omelettes, and more. Very limited seating inside, so I ate my food elsewhere.” -Yelp Review

6. Best Bagel & Coffee

It’s all in a name and since it says it’s the best it should go on the list!

📍 225 W 35th St A | New York | bestbagelandcoffee.com

If you’re going to say you’re the “Best Bagel & Coffee” then you should be able to back that up and from the looks of it- it seems like they have. Best Bagel & Coffee has thousands of five star reviews bringing their average rating on Google to 4.6/5 and 4.5/5 on Yelp.

• They feature eighteen different kinds of bagels to choose from, there’s Cinnamon Raisin, Egg, Everything, and Sun Dried Tomato Pesto. 
• Along with over 20 spreads including but not limited to Bacon & Cheddar, Vegetable Tofu, Banana Nutella, and Scallion. 
• And if you’re still hungry they also have breakfast & omelete platters, breakfast & lunch sandwiches both cold and hot, and salads. A great meal for the morning or afternoon. Find the best bagels in NYC at Best Bagel & Coffee.

“One of the best bagel spots in NYC! It's everything you want: crunchy outside and soft/chewy inside. There's always a line but it moves really quickly! Must try if you're in the neighborhood!!” -Yelp Review

7. Bagel to Sandwich

A spot known for the freshest bagels in the city that have gluten-free options as well!

📍 240 W 40th St suite 604 | New York | bageltosandwich.com

Bagel to Sandwich has everything from, you guessed it, bagels to sandwiches. Another recent opener that established itself in 2022, Bagel to Sandwich also known as BTS, prides itself on only using the finest and freshest of ingredients so every bite you take is better than the last. With hundreds of reviews they have a 4.7/5 stars on Google and 4.5/5 on Yelp which we love to see. 

Walk in and take a look around their chic atmosphere while you decide on what type of bagel to order. Get Instagram pictures by picking their Rainbow Bagel or go savory and get the Asiago Bagel. They have plenty of delicious spreads as well so you can mix and match to your heart’s content.

“I promise you want to pay this place a visit !

I wish I could right about now! I loved their bagels, I tried the rainbow bagel- honey bird definitely a great breakfast bagel they have so many cream cheese to choose from & the service there was good / helpful.” -Yelp Review

8. NYC Bagel & Coffee House (NYCBCH)

A small chain of bagel shops in the city makes for plenty to explore!

📍 332 8th Ave | New York | nycbch.com

If you’re a native or have been to New York before then there’s a good chance you have heard of or have been to NYC Bagel & Coffee House as they are a small local chain that has locations all up and down the city. Each location has an average rating on Google of 4.5+ stars which is great to see from this growing business. They’re in the business of making sure your food is of the highest quality and that means making everything to perfection, from the food to the drinks. Savory and sweet tooths alike will be able to find a bagel that fits their preferences as NYC Bagel & Coffee House has a little something for everyone.

“Food, atmosphere, variety, cleanliness, staff, we're all amazing and perfect. Everything was delicious and feeling, and I feel for for the dollar amount, It was quite reasonable for the amount of food you got.” -Yelp Review

9. Liberty Bagels (Midtown)

Another small chain of bagel shops rounds out our list for the best bagels in NYC!

📍 260 W 35th St | New York | libertybagels.com

Liberty Bagels is a hugely popular NYC chain that has four locations all over the city. And their average location rating on Google is 4.4+ stars which again, makes for a great visit. Their Midtown location is by far the best rated and as there have been thousands raving about just much it lives up to the hype online. You can see the community Liberty has built over the years and they have drawn quite the following online so it’s safe to assume that no matter what bagel you get, their Blueberry, Egg Everything, Jalapeno Cheddar, or the Instagram famous Rainbow, you’ll be looking for seconds.

“These bagels were so delicious! I got the jalepeno cheddar bagel as a power house. The service was great, busy but not impossibly to get in. The vibe inside was great too!” -Yelp Review

There are a lot of bagel shops in the city but finding the best bagels in NYC is a whole different story and we’ve taken a look and found that these places above fit the bill.