Get Your Steak Knives Ready For the Best Steakhouses in Atlanta

If You’re a Meat and Potatoes Kind of Person -- Look No Further Because This List Has You Covered

American traditional is one style of cuisine we all crave at least on a weekly basis -- this includes items like steak, seafood, and a hearty selection of sides to accompany our protein. In the south, many community members and visitors are on the hunt for the best steakhouse in the area. 

Atlanta boasts some of the best selections of steakhouses offering southern and New Orleans style cuisine as well as innovative takes on American classic comfort food. We’ve put together a list of the six best steakhouses offering these takes on American cuisine. Try them all to determine your favorite! 

Know someone on a quest to find the best steakhouse who will be in the Atlanta area soon? Surprise them with a GiftYa to a restaurant they’ve never been to. A GiftYa is an electronic gift card that can be bought, personalized, and sent directly to the recipient's phone -- making it a great option for birthday, holiday, and surprise gifting! However, Atlanta is just one of the 1.5 million locations across the United States that accepts GiftYa’s. They can also be purchased for much more than restaurants -- retailers, activities and recreations, hotels, personal, pet, and automotive services and more. This makes gifting easy and is a great way to send someone a gift with being safe and socially distant, especially if they live in a different state and you can’t travel there.  

1. Hal’s “The Steakhouse”

Modern space with 20 years of experience serving steaks and entrees

Just because you’re going to a steakhouse doesn’t mean you’re obligated to get steak! 

30 Old Ivy Rd NE | Atlanta |

Hal’s steakhouse has been serving loyal customers in the Atlanta area for 29 years with the help of their staff that has been together for over 20 years. They have award winning steaks, seafood, pasta dishes, soups and salads, and more. The menu is inspired by the cuisine of New Orleans and the atmosphere follows suit. The environment is an upscale, yet relaxed elegance complete with city lighting and live entertainment. 

Their menu offers upscale southern style appetizers like escargot and shrimp remoulade. These can be followed by a selection of salads, pastas, seafood, and of course what many people will be having -- steak. They offer a variety of cuts and sizes from filet to ribeye and even duck, lamb, and chicken. This menu carries enough to satisfy the cravings of every diner! 

“The BEST steak I have ever had (I got Hal's ribeye). The crème brûlée  was to die for as well. I ordered another one because it was THAT good.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa for Hal’s “The Steakhouse”

2. Kevin Rathbun Steak

Chef owned and operated steakhouse offering steak, seafood, and cocktails

Even though the steak is the star of the meal -- it’s all about the sides in our opinion!

154 Krog St NE STE 200 | Atlanta |

When chef Kevin Rathbun opened his restaurant, he invited Atlanta community members to experience a taste of his long term dream -- owning a steakhouse. His vision included everything from the dinner and cocktail menus to the dining atmosphere. The space is refurbished industrial with high ceilings, exposed brick walls, reclaimed wood, and original artwork, including a painted portrait of Kevin Rathbun himself. 

The menu offers creatively designed options courtesy of Kevin, his executive and sous chef, and his pastry chef. They boast fresh seafood, Allen brothers steaks, signature entrees, and delicious sides. The cocktail menu is designed based on the seasonal ingredients offered at that time, and they have an extensive wine list showcasing some of the best offerings in the world. 

“Went here for my birthday and I absolutely fell in love! The lobster fritters were a delicious appetizer with the perfect ratio of lobster and breading. I had the Pink Cadillac cocktail and it was tasty as well.” - Yelp Review 

Purchase a GiftYa for Kevin Rathbun Steak 

3. 101 Steak 

Various cuts of steak and 100 wines by the glass served at this modern location

Surf and turf meats asparagus and delicious sauces to dunk your dinner. 

3621 Vinings Slope SE | Atlanta |

101 Steak is a modern take on the traditional steakhouse. Their concept is largely based on a contemporary take on the dining atmosphere and the food. The atmosphere is upscale, and elegant with neutral colors and low lighting. The menu is chef driven, and features high quality steaks, seafood, raw offerings, and over 100 wines by the glass -- making it a connoisseur's dream. 

The menu features innovative takes on classic comfort food. The starters include conventional and unconventional options, entrees include a number of steaks in different cuts and weights, along with pasta, salads, chicken, burgers, and seafood. The night can be completed with a sample from the dessert menu which includes classic creme brulee, key lime mousse, chocolate layer cake, and NY style cheesecake and more. Be sure not to overlook the raw seafood options, as well as the sauce and butter offerings that can instantly upgrade your entree selection. 

“This is my absolute favorite steakhouse in Atlanta! Seating is spacious due to covid. The food is amazing and I recommend the Green Egg pork chop! The staff is knowledgeable and friendly.” - Yelp Review 

Purchase a GiftYa for 101 Steak

4. American Cut Steakhouse

Created by Iron Chef Marc Forgione featuring innovative dishes

Upscale and create entrees accompany prime cuts of steak at this location. 

3035 Peachtree Rd NE STE 140 | Atlanta |

Food network fans will rejoice over this steakhouse from Iron Chef America’s own Marc Forgione. He competed on the show and won season three of the Next Iron Chef. American Cut Steakhouse is one of his many restaurants and can be found in NYC and Atlantic City as well as Atlanta. The concept is modern upscale dining with many levels to the restaurant. 

The menu features raw offerings, hot and cold appetizers, salads, various cuts of steak, chicken, tuna, and halibut, as well as sides from your classic comfort mac'n'cheese to french fries and mashed potatoes. The night can be finished with sweets from the dessert menu and don’t forget the bar menu which includes cocktails, wine, beer, and ciders. Currently, the Atlanta location is temporarily closed due to the pandemic, but plans to reopen soon. 

“I always have a swanky good time here. Whether dressing up to sit and have upscale cocktails at the bar on the first floor, our having a birthday dinner upstairs with friends. I love their ribeye and sides.” - Yelp Review 

Purchase a GiftYa for American Cut Steakhouse

5. Highland Tap

Underground steakhouse serving American traditional 

Hearty cut of steak and baked potato meets martini with extra olives -- a meal fit for a star. 

1026 North Highland Ave NE | Atlanta |

Highland Tap is not your average fancy steakhouse. The atmosphere is remnant of an underground speakeasy style space. They have been around for 32 years and have come to serve a local clientele and are known for their steaks, burgers, cocktails, and martinis. 

On the menu, they have a lengthy list of cold and hot appetizers as well as soups and salads. All of their steaks are wood fired and cooked over hickory wood that gives their steaks a smoky, wood fired flavor. They also offer slow roasted prime rib, entrees of chicken, seafood, and lamb, and a hearty selection of burgers and sandwiches. Don’t pass up the side offerings -- they have American comfort classics that we’ll let you discover for yourself.  

“Cool environment, great food, and the prices aren't that bad.  The place has been retrofitted for COVID safety.  The staff always makes you feel welcome.” - Yelp Review 

Purchase a GiftYa for Highland Tap 

6. Cuts Steakhouse 

Fine dining complete with steak, seafood, and a number of delicious sides

Surf and turf -- southern fried lobster tail on top of a 16 oz prime rib. Image courtesy of Yelp.

60 Andrew Young International Blvd NE | Atlanta |

Cuts Steakhouse comes with more than 20 years of restaurant experience. They serve guests in a fine dining atmosphere and require business casual attire. Guests can dine in the main dining space, on the patio, or in a private room for a more intimate experience. The food is southern-style and the offerings are prime cuts of steak, southern seafood classics, and a lengthy selection of wine, beer, and cocktails. 

The menu features a list of appetizers, salad entrees, house special entrees, signature cuts of steak from ribeye to filet and new york strip, steak toppings, sauces, and sides. The night can end on a sweet note with a warm pecan fudge brownie or your choice from the dessert menu!

“We ate in person and the food was fantastic! Amazing server! So glad we came by. Everything was great from the drinks to the bread to the steaks to the sides!” - Yelp Review 

Purchase a GiftYa for Cuts Steakhouse

One of these six steakhouses is bound to delight your taste buds and leave you wanting to try more that Atlanta has to offer!

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts

Food & Drink
11 Best Restaurants for Breakfast + Brunch in Boise

From Sizzling Bacon to Fluffy Pancakes, Here Are the Best Places to Fuel Up with Breakfast and Brunch in The Gem State

Food & Drink
12 Restaurants That Serve the Best Brunch in Portland

From Pastries Shops to Old School Diners, Local Joints to National Chains, Here are the Absolute Best Places for Breakfast and Brunch in Portland, Oregon