Swinging by Little Italy in the Bronx? Check Out These Popular Arthur Avenue Restaurants

These Arthur Avenue restaurants will make you want to keep going back.

New York is home to some outstanding eateries, but one of its finest offerings is Italian food. If you’ve been to Little Italy in Manhattan and were disappointed, or the food didn’t meet your expectations, you might want to head down to Arthur Avenue – known to many throughout the area as the “real Little Italy.” Bronx’s Little Italy flies the multicolor flag from street corners and has as many trattorias, classic bakeries, and mozzarella stores as any neighborhood in the borough.

The area is popular for its red-sauce, Italian-American fare, and more. But all of Italy is represented here too, from rustic Tuscan dishes, to doughy Neapolitan pizza, to saucy Sicilian specialties. If you’re planning to wander down Arthur Avenue in the Bronx, here are the best Italian restaurants to grab some lunch or dinner.

If you’re in the area, you might be overwhelmed by the amazing variety of Italian restaurants in the Bronx. Regardless, GiftYa understands the struggle, especially the struggle of dining out in a big city like the Bronx, which doesn’t come at a cheap price. GiftYa virtual gift card allows you to find the best restaurant near you. They’re completely customizable and can be applied to several Italian restaurants in the Bronx. Order yours today!

1. Zero Otto Nove

Popular Italian restaurant serving Southern Italian classics in an airy storefront setting

2357 Arthur Avenue | The Bronx | zeroottonove.com

At first glance, the industrial-style interior will blow your mind. Wait until you look at their menu and you’ll understand why it’s one of the best Italian bistros in the Bronx. At Zero Otto Nove, the specialty is Salerno-style pizza, but most folks flock to this joint to get a taste of their perfectly crafted wood-fired Neapolitan-style pies, and some hearty and silky pasta dishes. If you want to experience something a little out of the box, try their La Riccardo Pizza served with squash puree, pancetta, smoked mozzarella, and basil.

While you won’t spot any Italian grandmas in the kitchen at this lovely eatery, you’ll probably find anything you would find in an Italian restaurant with some great attention to detail in their admirable presentation, service, and most importantly, the experience they provide for you.

“Not only was the food delicious but the service was great and my drink was really good too.” - Yelp Review

2. Dominick’s

Enjoy some family-style pasta on this old-fashioned Italian bistro in Little Italy in the Bronx

2335 Arthur Avenue | The Bronx | dominicks.com

Dominick’s is a popular, classy Italian restaurant located on Arthur Avenue and offers a wide array of hearty and saucy dishes. This unfussy, decades-old gem has been dishing out generous servings of well-prepared pasta for over five decades. Instead of just presenting you with menus, the waiters are courteous enough to let you order what you want depending on the current mood. You can start off with some pasta, salad, or fish then reel off to the main course. They prefer to do things the old-fashioned way by making their Italian dishes from scratch.

As for the entrees, you have a wide selection on the menu including the stuffed artichoke, sirloin steak served with some fries, chicken parm, baked ziti, and penne alla vodka. You can also enjoy their Sunday specials that include lasagna, cavatelli, beef braciole, and manicotti to end the week on a high note.

“We tossed around some other local places and decided on Dominick's. This was the perfect food for a rainy cold Sunday evening.” - Yelp Review 

3. Roberto’s

Experience the delicious taste of Salerno specials from Chef Roberto Paciullo’s Italian eatery

603 Crescent Avenue | The Bronx | robertosbronx.com

If what you’re searching for is some traditional Italian cuisine, then there’s no better place to visit than Roberto’s modern Italian fare. Here at Roberto’s, they will get you all the way there with a menu that combines both old-school Italian cuisines and some contemporary twists.

Chef Roberto has done an incredible job of turning his knowledge into a diverse menu that everyone will enjoy. You can’t miss this Italian-American favorite such as pasta, bunny stewed with potatoes, and seasonal vegetables steamed in cartoccio or in a foil pouch. The wine list is even more sophisticated to ensure you enjoy every sip after feasting on their delicious entrees.

They take their customer service a notch higher by ensuring that they make adjustments to their meals to fit their customers' dietary needs. In fact, they help you pick the best if you have no idea what to eat.

“Wonderful meal. Try their signature pasta- baked in foil plus anything else Also a must, their homemade cannoli made with an unusual twist.” - Yelp Review 

4. Enzo’s of Arthur Avenue

Get a taste of some Italian favorites in this cozy, modest neighborhood restaurant

2339 Arthur Avenue | The Bronx | enzosarthurave.com

In the heart of Arthur Avenue sits Enzo’s, a modest Italian restaurant popular for its red sauce and other Italian creations prepared from local and seasonal ingredients. You can stop by at any time at this Italian bistro and grab as many spicy sausages and broccoli rabe as you can.

You can also get some pasta, or their assorted cured meats served with artisanal cheeses and marinated vegetables, littleneck clam served with seasoned breadcrumbs, and their signature fried meatballs topped with sautéed onions and hot peppers. Their menu is pretty diverse, so if you’re in the mood for some orecchiette, ziti, or Insalata, you are sure to find them in plenty. If you feel a little overwhelmed, you can simply ask for assistance from their polite waiters.

“It just doesn't get any more Italian authentic than this place.  The delicious menu choices will make it hard to decide.” - Yelp Review 

5. Antonio’s Trattoria

Casual Italian eatery offering brick-oven pies and some home-made Italian classics

2370 Belmont Avenue | The Bronx | antoniostrattoria.com

What’s better than an Italian joint serving the best of Italian favorites in the Bronx. For Italians, a perfect traditional family dinner goes beyond just sitting around the table together and sharing some childhood memories.

To experience the true definition of dining in an Italian home, swing by Antonio’s Trattoria where you’ll find mouthwatering Italian dishes such as baked clams, brick-oven pizzas, and calzones, fried calamari, with fresh pasta including lasagna, penne, and rigatoni. Even the fussiest of eaters will fall in love with this.

On the menu, you’ll also find a variety of fresh pasta such as spaghetti with a choice of sausage, meatballs, or baked ziti Sorrentino, Borgatti's cheese served in a marinara sauce, gnocchi Caprese tossed in a plum tomato sauce with mozzarella, and more.

When you visit the restaurant, expect friendly, attentive service, and don’t forget to order some of their best wine and bottled beer.

“Excellent food. And exceptional service. The short ribs are delectable. The meat is so tender and juicy that it falls right off the bone.” - Yelp Review 

6. Emilio’s of Morris Park

Indulge your taste buds in an extensive Italian menu with classic pizzas, pasta, and more.

1051 Morris Park Avenue | The Bronx | emiliosofmorrispark.com

Located in Morris Park borough, Emilio’s Italian kitchen offers a wide selection of authentic Italian dishes. From white classic pizzas, sandwiches, and calzones to linguini with chicken, clams, and eggplant parm, this popular Italian restaurant is the real deal.

Whether you’re in the mood for some fresh entrees and seafood, or even a whole specialty pizza prepared in their traditional way, they’ve got a little bit of everything for everyone here at Emilio’s.

If you’re craving desserts, you can go for the sheet cakes available in all flavors or try the cannoli cakes. For appetizers, get to choose from buffalo wings to chicken fingers to mozzarella sticks. In the meantime, don’t forget to try some of their delicious selection of beverages including pure leaf tea flavors, brisk iced tea, Crush orange, and more.

“You can get a solid slice from here with high quality ingredients. I look forward to welcoming it back into my portfolio of go-to pizzerias in the Bronx.” - Yelp Review 

7. F & J Pine Restaurant

A popular feasting spot serving classic Italian cuisines enlivened with modern techniques

1913 Bronxdale Avenue | The Bronx | fjpine.com

Whether you’re craving some classic entrees such as steak and seafood dishes or the delicious pasta, you won’t be disappointed once you make your way to F & J Pine. Their welcoming raw bar and pizza oven are especially loved by the regulars here, offering up both extensive recipes and delicious flavors for you to enjoy.

Frankie & Johnie’s Tavern, as it’s locally referred to, also serves other mouth-watering dishes such as chicken parm, Frank’s popular ragu, and Nonna’s meatballs. Their portions are big with additional varieties for lunch and dinner including their stuffed artichoke served with parmesan, breadcrumbs, prosciutto, and lemon batter. You might also want to try their pasta that includes a variety of dishes like linguini with clams and chopped littleneck clams, garlic, and olive oil.

When it comes to cocktails and wines, you have a wide selection of options to choose from. You can opt for martini options or their signature cocktails or even try their mojitos, and draft beers. Without a doubt, there’s plenty for you to spread out and enjoy some great time with your loved ones here. Don’t skip out on their gluten-free selections and be sure to wash it down with their tasty wine.

“Love finding little hidden gems. The restaurant is warm and welcoming. The service was great. The food was delicious!” - Yelp Review

8. Mario’s

A family-owned Neapolitan-Italian restaurant is just what you need when dining in Little Italy in the Bronx

 

2342 Arthur Avenue | The Bronx | mariosarthurave.com

Are you looking for a family-owned restaurant to dine in and support local businesses in The Bronx? Make sure to check out Mario’s today! With over one hundred years of business, this is a restaurant to be because you will be treated like family and you can enjoy some insanely good food too.

Mario’s is just the place that you need to go to on Arthur Avenue in The Bronx. Try out the fried calamari, lasagna, eggplant rollatini, eggplant parm, manicotti, alla vodka, and so much more. Don’t miss out on Marios’s and support some local businesses on Arthur Avenue right now!

“Super traditional old fashioned restaurant in the heart of Little Italy. Really enjoyed the people, food and outdoor dining experience.” - Yelp Review 

9. San Gennaro

Pasta and wine is the perfect combination for dinner, so try out this restaurant

2329 Arthur Avenue | The Bronx | sangennarorestaurant.com

Do you enjoy just a simple pasta and wine combination for dinner? If so, then you need to check out San Gennaro as soon as you can! This incredible restaurant on Arthur Avenue is perfect because the food is 100% authentic with the chef being from Napoli, Italy cooking up some of the best Italian dishes around.

San Gennaro has some amazing dishes that you need to try out ASAP. From baked clams, grilled octopus, burrata, eggplant parm, chicken San Gennaro, octopus flowers, zucchini flowers, and so much more. Make sure to come to San Gennaro for dinner in the Bronx today!

“Quiet corner of Little Italy in the Bronx. Great Italian flavors. Even the pizza tasted extra special.” - Yelp Review 

10. Gerbasi

An upscale Italian restaurant is just what you need to try out for lunch or dinner

2389 Arthur Avenue | The Bronx | gerbasiristorante.org

Are you into more upscale dining? If you want some Italian food for an upscale dining experience, then you need to come check out Gerbasi on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx today! Gerbasi is known for their beautiful patio setting serving authentic Italian dishes that are perfect for date night or even just catching up with friends and family.

Gerbasi has a lot that you can choose from off of their menu, ranging from fried calamari, pear and gorgonzola salad, chicken parmesan, eggplant parmesan, chicken marsala, pork chop pizzaiola, ribeye steak, and much more. Check out Gerbasi right now and book a reservation for dinner!

“Everything was just perfect! George and Luis were so professional and courteous. And the food was the best!!” - Yelp Review 

11. Ann & Toby’s

Sometimes an old-school family diner is just what you need

2407 Arthur Avenue | The Bronx | annandtonysonline.com

There is just something about old-school family diners that just makes them so comfortable to be in. Ann & Toby’s is the perfect place to go to whenever you’re walking along Arthur Avenue looking for some of the best Italian restaurants in the Bronx! Serving authentic Italian dishes since 1927, this is a restaurant that you don’t want to miss out on.

Ann & Toby’s has everything you need when it comes to tasty and authentic Italian food. Make sure to try out the chicken parm, penne alla vodka, gnocchi, shrimp, veal, chicken marsala, and so much more. Why not give Ann & Toby’s a try today!

“I'm very much satisfied with Ann & Tony's Restaurant. The value is exceptional. Very yummy and also healthy.” - Yelp Review 

12. Tapas Italiano

Do you like eating tapas? Come to this Italian restaurant that serves the best around

2363 Arthur Avenue | The Bronx | tapasitaliano.com

Do you like eating tapas and other tasty Italian favorites? Why not check out Tapas Italiano on Arthur Avenue in The Bronx right now! This amazing restaurant serves tapas, seafood, and some delicious authentic Italian dishes that you truly can’t miss out on. Enjoy the serene and calming setting as you dive into some amazing Italian dishes.

Want to know what kind of dishes that they have for you to try? Come try out their fried ravioli, bruschetta, rigatoni, wedge salads, burgers, tapas, fried calamari, and lots more. Don’t miss out on Tapas Italiano and some of the incredible dishes that they can offer you!

“All of the staff are very courteous - you truly feel welcome and taken care of. Happy Tapas Italiano customers every single time.” - Yelp Review 

13. Emilia’s

Charming Italian restaurant on Arthur Avenue that is known for its friendly, low-key vibes

Take a seat outside and enjoy some delicious Italian food! Image courtesy of Emilia’s

2331 Arthur Ave | Belmont | emiliasrestaurant.com

Whether you want to grab a quick bite before a Yankees game or fuel up after a long day at the Bronx Zoo, Emilia’s is the perfect spot for authentic Italian food and drinks. On the menu, you’ll find mouthwatering Italian dishes like the Gnocchi con Burrata, Penne alla Vodka, Chicken Parmigiana, and Pork Osso Buco. 

Hosting a private event? Emilia’s offers special catering packages that include restaurant favorites like the Gnocchi Bolognese and Cheese Ravioli. Check out their menu online now!

“The food was phenomenal: that antipasto platter had creamy fresh mozzarella, bracingly salty prosciutto, smoky roasted peppers, briny olives, and a truffle provolone) while the pastas were cooked perfectly (the vodka sauce not too heavy, with just enough punch while the bolognese was rich and meaty).” - Yelp Review

14. Trattoria Zero Otto Nove

Popular Italian restaurant that is known for its savory thin-crust pizzas

Try the Rigatoni e Zucca! Image courtesy of Yelp.

2357 Arthur Ave | Belmont | zeroottonove.com

Summer is finally here, so it’s the perfect time to dine outside! Luckily for you, Trattoria offers a stunning outdoor patio perfect for kicking back and relaxing with your friends. 

Located on Arthur Avenue, Trattoria is known for its extensive selection of authentic Italian food like the Salmon con Vegetali, Pollo Scarpariello, and Pasta al Forno. Are you already foaming at the mouth? Reserve a table at Trattoria for your next meal! The restaurant is open Tuesday through Sunday for lunch and dinner. 

“Service was exceptional and food was nothing but delicious. We all had fun and it was a nice day spent together. We will be back for sure.” - Yelp Review

15. Arthur Ave Fiasco

Low-key Italian eatery that is known for its pasta and pizza

Buy a gift card for Fiasco

2376 Arthur Ave | Belmont | arthuravefiasco.com

Fiasco on Arthur Avenue offers a cozy, low-key dining space that will put you right at ease. It’s the perfect spot to unwind after a long day! Not only can you expect friendly, professional service, but you can also expect to find some of the best Italian food on Arthur Ave.

Hearty dishes like Gnocchi al Tartufo, Penne Vodka, and Pork Chop Caprese await you at this popular restaurant. Thirsty? Fiasco also offers a full wine and beer menu. Check out the full menu online now!

“I was referred here by a local. I’m so grateful! This place was clean, quiet, and friendly. The food was better than expected and the prices were reasonable. I will 100% make this place my Arthur Ave go to!” - Yelp Review

Buy a gift card for Fiasco

16. Joe’s Italian Deli

Locally-owned deli in Belmont that serves Italian meats, pastas, and more

Buy a gift card for Joe’s Italian Deli

685 E 187th St | Belmont | joesitaliandeli.com

Joe’s Italian Deli is known for its imported Italian cheeses, meats, pastas, and sauces. Whether you need to make a quick grocery run or grab a sandwich for lunch, Joe’s Italian Deli has just what you need. 

For over 40 years, locals have made Joe’s Italian Deli their go-to spot for fresh sandwiches and ingredients. Hosting a small party? Joe’s also offers catering specials that can feed up to 100 people. Check out their website for more information!

“A first class establishment!! I took advantage of the free shipping by ordering over $100.00. The Felino Salami, Incanestrato, Artigiano, and Scamorza cheese are amazing. Packaging was very good, with a hand written thank you note.” - Yelp Review

Buy a gift card for Joe’s Italian Deli

17. Michaelangelo’s Little Italy

Romantic Italian restaurant that serves hearty brick-oven pies

Baked Ziti, Ribeye Steak, Lobster Ravioli Pasta, and more hearty dishes await you! Image courtesy of Yelp.

2477 Arthur Ave | Belmont 

Next on the list is Michaelangelo’s Little Italy. This restaurant offers a wide selection of pizzas, pastas, salads, soups, and more authentic Italian dishes. Some of our favorite plates include the Risotto Arancini, Margarita Pizza, and Stuffed Mushrooms. 

Have a bit of a sweet tooth? Michaelangelo’s offers delicious desserts like Cream Filled Cannoli and Cheesecake! Try out Michaelangelo’s for your next meal. 

“Trying to find a new pizza place to order from and this place is a strong contender. We ordered the Margarita A La Petrit and it's really good. Will order again.” - Yelp Review

18. Pasquale’s Rigoletto 

A pasta haven in Little Italy in the Bronx. 

Creamy pastas are a staple at this restaurant. Image courtesy of Yelp

2311 Arthur Ave | Bronx | pasqualesrigoletto.com

Pasquale’s offers a variety of Italian foods like clams, calamari, and pasta. You’ll get to choose from a number of pastas with different sauces and toppings, like penne vodka with shrimp, fettuccine alfredo, and fettuccine bolognese. 

This restaurant comes with great decor and a friendly staff, so you’ll get to enjoy your meal in a great atmosphere. You definitely won’t regret checking this place out!

“Wonderful place, great people. Being a big fan of baked clams, I've never tasted fresher. Often a special, if they have it, try the pork braciole, with homemade cavatelli. It is a tradition, Arthur Avenue, great food, and a real family experience. Please try Pasquale Rigoberto.”–Yelp Review

19. Full Moon Pizza

Pizza that comes straight from a provincial town in Salerno, Italy. 

600 E 187th St | Bronx | fullmoonpizza.com

Full Moon Pizza began as a small kitchen in Italy and now serves up amazing Italian food right in the Bronx. It offers delicious family recipes that will make you want to come back time and time again. 

This family business will show you a good time, and they will show you while honoring their core values of good company, soul warming food, and family. When you visit this restaurant, you will always be treated like family. 

“Solid NYC style pizza. The slices are generous, the crust is crispy, and the cheese to tomato ratio is practically perfect.”–Yelp Review

There is no shortage of authentic and hospitable Italian eateries in the Bronx and this list will help you narrow down to the most outstanding joints you’re yet to try. So, which restaurants are your favorites? Let us know in the comments!

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts

Food & Drink
Enjoy An Incredible Night At Any Of These Downtown Charleston Restaurants

We’ve got an array of incredible dishes served up from some of Charleston’s best!

Food & Drink
Black Owned Restaurants In Charleston, SC

Black Owned restaurants are thriving in the city of Charleston.