Top 3 Seafood Restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana

Finding good seafood in the Midwest can sometimes feel like searching for water in the desert.

But while the city isn't necessarily known for its fish, Indy has several hidden gems awaiting seafood-craving locals and visitors alike.

Finding the best seafood in Indianapolis, Indiana is good for more than just choosing your next date night destination. It's also a great choice for when you need to choose a gift card to mark a special occasion for a friend or loved one. From weddings and anniversaries to birthdays and retirements, a gift card to a nice seafood restaurant is always a good choice.

When you choose a virtual GiftYa card, you can quickly and easily send your gift card with a personalized note. Your recipient will receive it right away so that they can get out and enjoy a special night and some delicious food without delay.

Whether you're looking for your own new favorite date night spot or the perfect one to gift to a friend, keep reading to learn the top 3 seafood restaurants in Indianapolis.

1. The Oceanaire Seafood Room

A swanky, world-class restaurant serving up the freshest seafood in Indianapolis

Image courtesy of Yelp.

30 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

When it comes to fresh, delicious, perfectly-prepared seafood, nowhere in Indianapolis can beat The Oceanaire Seafood Room. From crabcakes, caviar, and oysters on the appetizer menu, to decadent lobster pot pie, Alaska king crab, Ahi tuna, scallops, and a variety of other meals, you'll find it all here. Visit just once and you'll quickly see why this restaurant is consistently rated among the top in the city.

The Oceanaire Seafood Room doesn't let its Midwest location get in the way of diners enjoying fresh seafood. Instead, they fly in fresh catches every day from around the world. For those who prefer something other than fish, you'll also find a section of prime steakhouse cuts.

But the incredible flavors don't end when the main course does; you'll definitely want to leave room for dessert when you dine. Their signature dessert is the Oceanaire Baked Alaska, served flaming in a show that's almost as impressive as the taste of this special sweet treat. Other options include a decadent dark chocolate flourless torte, apple and pear fruit crisp, key lime pie, and cheesecake.

Looking to dine on fresh seafood, but on a budget? Visit The Oceanaire Seafood Room on a Sunday. That's when you'll find $1 oysters served at the bar, from open to close every week. Pair your oysters with your favorite cocktail for a special date night—or your new Sunday afternoon tradition!

"The COVID quarantine has had me staying home and making more meals so I decided to step out today for my birthday.Oceanaire was definitely the kind of place to come out of hibernation. The upscale service was matched by the quality of our meals.We started off with their version of Oysters Rockefeller. The Oysters were not overshadowed by the traditional Hollandaise type sauce. In fact there was only the. oysters, spinach and what appeared to be crispy pancetta. This was the perfect opener.

The wedge salad provided ample bleu cheese, same pancetta and an amazing dressing.

I ordered the crab cakes. In the Maryland area, crab cakes have very little filler. These crab cakes were served like that. Very flavorful.

My wife ordered the chicken fried lobster with cheese grits served with a side of spicy sauce. This dish stole the show. The lobster was sweet while the breading was crunchy and slightly salty.The side dish of sautéed spinach was just average compared to the entrees.

Overall this was a great dining experience." -Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for The Oceanaire Seafood Room.

2. Tony's of Indianapolis

A decadent steakhouse featuring a raw bar and other seafood selections

Blackened Yellow Fin tuna, lobster tails, and ahi tuna are just a few of the seafood selections at this world-class steakhouse. Image courtesy of Yelp.

110 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

Tony's of Indianapolis might not be as well known for its steaks as its seafood. But that doesn't stop it from being a must-see if you're visiting Indy, as well as for locals. To start, it's not just a great steakhouse; it's nationally recognized. It's been named a top steakhouse in the nation, as well as one of Indy's most romantic restaurants, making it a great choice for a date night out.

The downtown location and elegant decor make dining at Tony's as much about the experience as it is about the delicious food. You'll be greeted as friends, as staff does everything they can to ensure that you have a great experience.

While Tony's of Indianapolis might be best known for its steaks, it offers a variety of fresh seafood options as well. On the raw bar, you'll find oysters, shrimp cocktails, and Alaska king crab. Entrees include Scottish salmon, blackened Yellow Fin tuna, shrimp and grits, Chilean sea bass, and more.

"Had a beautiful prepared meal and service was awesome! We got the crab cake as the appetizer and it was amazing. I generally don't like crab cake but you can tell they used real ingredients.

Wife got the salmon and I got the porterhouse. Salmon was great! Good sized portion for the salmon and the green beans that came with it were good.

Time to review the porterhouse (24oz). It's was cooked PERFECT and seasoned very well. Had great flavor and was pretty much fall off the bone. My only complaint was it was a little salty for me. However, the manager said they put this in our customer profile and remember for next time. Which I thought was an amazing idea.

All the old fashioned's were amazing and I had 4 different ones. Would highly recommend over St. Elmos ANYDAY." -Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Tony's of Indianapolis.

3. Ocean World

A fun, modern restaurant serving up fresh made suchi selections

Image courtesy of Yelp.

1206 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260

For a different take on fresh sushi in Indianapolis, head to Ocean World Sushi House. Here, you'll find a variety of freshly made sushi favorites. From California rolls and Nigiri to Tekka don and other traditional Japanese classics, the restaurant is a sushi-lovers paradise.

Chef George Sato founded the restaurant and continues to work as its executive chef. Having grown up in Ibarki, Japan, Chef Sato continues to draw influence from his family's roots, as well as from his own extensive travels. He often chooses to take a fresh take on classic ingredients, which makes the restaurant's sushi as unique as its vibrant decor.

"There are few things that are worth leaving the house for at this point in the pandemic, but one of those is the Bob's Roll at Ocean World. So when my husband found himself getting ready to celebrate a birthday during a time when the world is falling apart, we chose to spend our precious pennies on a takeout meal from Ocean World.

Of course, we got the Bob's Roll (two orders). But we also got the Nigiri Top Ten, which was 10 pieces of nigiri sushi and a choice of a sushi roll. It also came with a side salad. It was delicious and oh-so visually appealing.

We also got a California Roll (for the kids) and an appetizer side of crispy chicken, which came with a sweet chili sauce. I could have sat and ate five orders of crispy chicken (on the couch, in my pajamas, trying not to cry, as one does right now) that's how good it was.

Our meal was excellent in general, but considering we got it to go and ate it at home, I was really impressed with the quality. It was almost as good as visiting the restaurant and eating in person." -Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Ocean World.

Whether you're an avid seafood lover or are just looking for the perfect spot to mark a special occasion like an anniversary, birthday, or other celebration, you can't go wrong with one of these options. Indianapolis, Indiana might be a long way from either coast. But that doesn't mean that you can't enjoy a delicious meal of fresh seafood like crab legs, lobster, sushi, and more. If you need a spot for dinner for yourself or are looking for the right choice to purchase a gift card to for a friend or loved one, pick one of the top 3 seafood restaurants in Indianapolis.

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts

Food & Drink
Enjoy An Incredible Night At Any Of These Downtown Charleston Restaurants

We’ve got an array of incredible dishes served up from some of Charleston’s best!

Food & Drink
Black Owned Restaurants In Charleston, SC

Black Owned restaurants are thriving in the city of Charleston.