Kosher Restaurants in NYC You Have to Try

October 27, 2020
Food & Drink
jason wolfe
This is some text inside of a div block.

Whether you have just decided to start eating kosher or you have been following the tradition your whole life, you have a wide array of dining options to choose from in New York City. One of the best things about the Big Apple is that there is something for every diet and taste bud here. Don’t know where to start? No worries! We’re going over our top picks for kosher restaurants in the city now!

Looking for a gift for your loved one? Surprise them with a virtual GiftYa card! GiftYa cards can be applied to a number of restaurants around New York City, including the ones featured below. Whether your loved one is in the mood for some cheese pizza or a savory hamburger, their GiftYa card can take them wherever their cravings direct them. In New York City, there is no shortage of exciting restaurants to try! 

1. Reserve Cut

Upscale steakhouse featuring a wine room and French-Asian cuisine

The Sushi Platter From Heaven is sure to delight your taste buds. Image courtesy of Yelp

40 Broad St, Floor 2 | Financial District |

If you are in the mood for some delicious sushi and Asian cuisine, stop by the Reserve Cut! Located in the Financial District, this popular kosher restaurant features a spacious dining room filled with Asian-inspired decor. Along with the main dining room, you will find a sushi bar and wine room inside.

Since 2013, Reserve Cut has served delicious dishes such as their Norwegian Salmon Filet and their Colorado Rack of Lamb. If you want something on the lighter side, you can pick a dish from the restaurant’s extensive sushi menu. Some of their most popular signature rolls include the Crispy Almond Triple and Tuna Poke Roll. 

“The service was outstanding, there was always someone there to take our plates away as soon as we finished, or fill our water once we took a sip. My water was never halfway full! Additionally, the restaurant was stunning inside. Even though it was pricey, it was worth it, and I would recommend it to anyone! A must try!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Reserve Cut.

2. Bravo Kosher Pizza

Popular deli found in the heart of Lower Manhattan

Craving pizza? Bravo Kosher Pizza offers an array of fun and exciting options! Image courtesy of Yelp

17 Trinity Pl, Suite B | Financial District |

If you are in the mood for something a little more laid back and casual, you will enjoy Bravo Kosher Pizza. Located between Lady Liberty and One World Trade, this vibrant pizza shop offers an array of delicious menu items. Whether you want a slice of authentic New York style pizza or a bowl of chicken soup, you are sure to leave Bravo Kosher Pizza feeling filled and satisfied. 

Not sure what to get? You can’t go wrong with the Corned Beef Omelette or the Pastrami Burger. For something on the lighter side, we recommend the California Salad or Grilled Chicken Wrap. Once things are back to normal and you can throw events again, consider contacting Bravo Kosher for all of your catering needs! Bravo Kosher offers both deli and pizza catering. 

“Pleasantly surprised by this Pizza! It was very good and we had the most amazing chocolate chunk cookie! The cookie was so darn good I wished I would have bought a second one of later! The pizza maker was very friendly to us! Great experience!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Bravo Kosher Pizza. 

3. La Brochette

Premier kosher restaurant serving French dishes inside an upscale dining room

Photo of La Brochette - New York, NY, United States
Treat yourself to a fine kosher dish! Image courtesy of Yelp

340 Lexington Ave | Murray Hill, Midtown East |

Because of lockdown measures enacted during the start of the pandemic, La Brochette had to temporarily close down. But this popular kosher restaurant is back and better than ever!

For lunch and dinner, you will find delicious sushi bar options such as the Spicy Tuna Dip and the Tuna Tataki. You can also select specialty rolls like the La Brochette roll, which features spicy tuna, avocado, and mayo. If you’re in the mood for something meatier, we recommend the Chicken Club Sandwich or Lamb Burger. Upscale options like the Center Cut Rib Eye and Filet Mignon are always a great choice as well. 

“A couple of us came to la brochette for a birthday celebration. Food was amazing. We got the la brochette sampler — amazing!! The steak and short ribs were phenomenal. Best of all was the mousse -— to die for!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for La Brochette.

4. King David Restaurant

Popular kosher restaurant serving a variety of delicious foods

Their sushi always makes for a great meal! Image courtesy of Yelp

101-10 Queens Blvd | Forest Hills |

Since 1998, King David has served delicious and creative meals to the people of New York City. Whether you are in the mood for some hearty pasta or chicken kebab, King David has all of this and more! 

To start your meal off right, try one of their cold appetizers like the Sushi Platter and the Sesame Tuna. Their Pickled Mushroom Salad and Zucchini Roll are also great for holding you over until your main entree arrives. Speaking of the main entree, you have an array of mouthwatering options to choose from. Everything from the Prime Beef Steak to the Cornish Chicken Tabaka is made with great skill and care. 

“It is one of the best Kosher restaurants in New York for any family occasion. I have personally used them for over 10 years. Delicious cuisine and a very welcoming atmosphere. You can even customize the menu for your occasion.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for King David Restaurant.   

UN Plaza Grill

5. UN Plaza Grill

Lavish grill serving hearty portions of steaks and authentic Japanese dishes

One of their most popular dishes is the Pistachio Salmon. Image courtesy of Yelp

845 1st Ave | Midtown East |

Looking for some fresh and zesty summer cuisine? Then you will want to add the UN Plaza Grill to your NYC restaurant bucket list! Located in Midtown East, UN Plaza Grill offers great options including burgers, salad, pizza, and ribeye. 

Stopping by for Happy Hour? UN Plaza Grill offers delicious Mini Burgers and Lamb Shank Samosas meant to enjoy alongside creative cocktails. Speaking of cocktails, you will find creative options such as the Lychee Martini and White Tiger to enjoy alongside your meal. 

“I started with the UN Old Fashioned. It was a delicious cocktail. They made a lemonade for my husband and our friend had Prosecco. For appetizers we had the  lamb pot stickers and the chilled pea soup. They were delicious.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for UN Plaza Grill.

6. Holy Schnitzel

Fast-food restaurant on the Upper West Side 

Try the Holy Toasty the next time you stop by. Image courtesy of Yelp

645 Amsterdam Ave | Upper West Side |

Holy Schnitzel is a popular kosher restaurant found in numerous locations around New York City, including the Upper West Side, Queens, and Brooklyn. At each branch, you are sure to be welcomed with a friendly staff ready to help you find the perfect dish to satisfy your cravings. Wraps, burgers, salads, and more can be found at this popular restaurant!

At the Upper West Side location, you can find exciting options such as the BBQ Chicken Wrap, Bacon Avocado Burger, Wings. Specialty sandwiches such as The Holy Schnitzel and The Buffalo Chicken sandwich are also popular among customers. 

“Such an amazing sandwich! I got a cornflake fried chicken with tahini, ketchup and chimichurri. Great quality chicken, perfect amount (very large portion) and really quick delivery with DoorDash. Will definitely deliver from there again.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Holy Schnitzel. 

7. Talia’s Steakhouse  

Lively kosher steakhouse located on the Upper West Side

Treat yourself to some ribs and fries! Image courtesy of Yelp.

668 Amsterdam Ave | Upper West Side |

For over 18 years, NYC residents have flocked to Talia’s Steakhouse for its delicious cuisine and drinks. Savory dishes such as their Moroccan Cigars and Chicken Schnitzel await you! Known for its elegant and intimate atmosphere, Talia’s Steakhouse is a top destination for romantic dinners. On each table, you will find a set of dimly-lit candles and fresh roses. On certain nights, live music is also featured throughout the dining room. 

“Me and my wife usually enjoy sitting at this restaurant, however, due to the circumstances we had to take out today. Nevertheless, dinner was perfect as usual. We love the BBQ spare ribs. By far the best kosher restaurant in the area. Highly recommended!” - Yelp Review 

Purchase a GiftYa card for Talia’s Steakhouse. 

Dining out in New York City is always an adventure! What are your favorite places to stop by for a special meal? Let us know in the comments!


Written by

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Learn more