Top 9 Restaurants That Serve the Best Pizza in Boston

This is some text inside of a div block.

Pizza is a signature comfort food. It’s delicious, versatile, and budget-friendly! Whether you’re planning a casual get-together with friends or organizing a laid back birthday celebration, pizza is almost always a prime food choice to include. And you’ll find plenty of pizza in Boston. No, the city won’t reach the heights of New York City fame for its pizza, but it does house an appetizing selection of pizzerias. From low-key, family-owned joints to upscale eateries, Boston offers something for everyone. Having trouble finding a good spot near you? We researched and found the top 9 pizzerias in Boston just for you. 

Searching for the perfect gift for your loved ones? Surprise them with a virtual GiftYa card! GiftYa offers a wide selection of virtual gift cards to some of the most popular places around Boston. Within seconds, you can send your loved one a GiftYa card to their favorite restaurant or store. To make the gift extra special, you can add a personal note to the card. Check out our full selection of cards now!

1. Regina Pizzeria

Popular pizzeria in the North End that has been serving happy customers since 1926

11 ½ Thacher St | North End |

Located appropriately in Boston’s Little Italy, Regina Pizzeria has welcomed thousands of guests from around the country. Regina Pizzeria has certainly earned its reputation as one of the best pizzerias in Boston, having even been named #1 pizzeria in the United States by Trip Advisor. It’s also been named the official pizza of the Boston Red Sox! 

All of the pizzas are made from a 95-year-old recipe using a special natural yeast that has been aged and proofed to perfection. The sauce is made up of a variety of herbs and spices and only the freshest ingredients from local producers are used for toppings.  

“We opted for a cheese pizza, which we split among three of us, and it made for the most fulfilling lunch. The pizza was delicious! Everything tasted so fresh, and you could tell that they only used high-quality ingredients. All in all, we had the best experience at Regina Pizzeria.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Regina Pizzeria. 

2. Santarpio's Pizza

Popular pizzeria in East Boston that started out as a bakery

Branch out and try something different like the Shrimp Scampi Pizza. Image courtesy of Yelp.

111 Chelsea St | East Boston |

Craving some thin crust pizza? Santarpio’s Pizza is the place to be. Located in East Boston, Santarpio’s features a wide selection of different types of pies like the Shrimp Scampi and The Works, which includes mushrooms, onions, peppers, garlic, sausage, pepperoni, and anchovies. 

If none of the specialty pizzas catch your eye, you can create your own instead! Santarpio’s also offers savory BBQ dishes such as sausage, chicken tips, and steak. Thirsty? Order some wine or beer from the restaurant’s extensive drink list to complete your meal.   

“This place does not need my review - it is iconic and worth the wait if the line spans two blocks. I love the grilled meats, obviously the pizza, but you cannot forget the hot peppers & bread. Honestly, just writing this makes me want to go back!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Santarpio's Pizza.

3. Brighton’s Best Pizza

Popular Mom and Pop restaurant that offers all of the necessities

Want to spend the night at home? Order in some pizza and put on a movie! Image courtesy of Yelp

600 Washington St | Boston |

Like many of the restaurants featured on the list, Brighton’s Best Pizza is the perfect place to organize a casual kickback with friends or family members. If you want something simple, you can order a cheese pizza with one, two, or three toppings. If you’re craving something more flavorful, you have a wide selection for specialty pizzas to choose from. Chicken Caesar Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, New Mexican Hot Pizza and other exciting specials await you at this popular restaurant. Calzones, cheesy breadsticks, wings, fries, and other savory appetizers are also available to complement your fresh pizza pie. 

Still hungry for dessert? Brighton’s Best Pizza offers frozen yogurt, cheesecake, and chocolate cake on the dessert menu. It also offers delicious smoothies like the Oreo Chiller Shake Smoothie and Mango Pina Colada Smoothie. Yum! 

“This is my favorite everyday eatery in Boston — and it certainly helps that it is so close to my house. HUGE menu selection ensures there is something for everyone. They have amazingly long business hours so they're almost always open when you want them to be, and they have frozen yogurt and other desserts, which is a menu area often lacking in sub shops.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Brighton’s Best Pizza. 

4. Ernesto’s Pizza

Beloved pizza parlor in the North End that has been open for over 20 years

Who wants a slice of the Big Mac pizza? Image courtesy of Yelp.

69 Salem St | North End |

Since opening over 30 years ago, Ernesto’s North End has attracted thousands of hungry guests looking for some delicious pizza. Both locals and visitors alike love the restaurant for its authentic and savory Italian dishes.

All of the pizza is served in extra large 18” pies. You can order a cheese pizza and add your own toppings like spinach and anchovies or try one of their many specialty pizzas. Some of our favorite pies include the BBQ Chicken, Chicken Roni Ricotta, and Cheeseburger pizza. Garden, Caesar, and Greek salads are also available if you would like to accompany your pizza with something light. 

“I would argue the best pizza on the North End. I go back and forth between here and Regina's. This is a casual stop on Salem street, cash or card here. They make all the pizza fresh throughout the day. I love the pepperoni and ricotta pizzas. My wife loves the BBQ chicken pizza, also BOMB. Fire.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Ernesto’s Pizza. 

5. Galleria Umberto

Sicilian style pizza served in laid back, casual atmosphere

289 Hanover St | North End |

Galleria Umberto is another popular pizzeria located in the North End of Boston. Made Sicillian style, the pizza features fresh cheese, fluffy crust, and savory sauce. Galleria offers other Italian specialties including paninis and calzones. The selection may be small compared to other restaurants on the list, but each dish is made with the freshest ingredients by some of the most skilled chefs in the city.

Pro tip: make sure you come early. You’ll see people waiting in line for pizza as early as 10am. At a mere $2 per slice, it’s no wonder that Galleria Umberto’s pizza is so popular among locals. Also, the restaurant is cash only so make sure you hit up an ATM before you arrive. 

“The pizza is perfect Sicilian style. That browned cheese, fluffy crust, not overly sauced. My stomach is growling. Simple is delicious and they are absolutely hitting the mark. They have a few things on the menu but we were there for the pizza. I go to Boston each year so I'll be back for more, no doubt about it.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Galleria Umberto. 

6. Florina Pizzeria & Paninoteca

Popular restaurant in Beacon Hill featured on Barstool Sports for its delicious pizza

16 Derne St | Downtown, Beacon Hill |

Florina Pizzeria & Paninoteca is one of the most popular pizzerias in Boston. It was ranked among the 10 Best Places to Get Pizza in Boston by Yelp as well as the top 5 Neighborhood Pizza Places for Back-to-School in Boston by Forbes. As soon as you take a bite out of one of their signature pizzas, you’ll see why it is so popular among visitors.

Guests can order cheese and roni pizza by the slice. The restaurant also offers a special Slice of the Day. Regular and premium toppings like chicken, pepperoni, caramelized onion, and more are available to customize your pizza. But if you’re not into building your own pizza, you can choose one of the many specialty pizzas featured on the menu. 

“Their pizza has been voted the best pizza in Boston, and they really weren't kidding! I grew up in New Jersey so I know good New York style pizza and I was thoroughly impressed with their slice! It was also HUGE, it's basically two slices in one! And at a great price too, I will definitely be coming here more often.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Florina Pizzeria & Paninoteca.

7. Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar

Chic and rustic pizzeria known for its savory organic dishes

345 Congress St | Fort Point |

If you’re looking for a more upscale spot where you can dress up a little, you’ll love Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar. Pastoral ARTisan is known for its savory pizzas made from fresh, organic ingredients. Both gluten and gluten-free pizzas are available to guests. 

Our favorite pizzas include the Margherita, Pomodoro, and Fennel Sausage. But whatever option you choose, you are sure to be pleased with it. In addition to their wide pizza selection, Pastoral ARTisan also serves authentic Italian dishes like Mezzi Rigatoni and Bucatini. 

“Pastoral - Artisan Pizza, Kitchen & Bar you are simply magnificent, I had a lovely experience here yesterday. It has a great vibe to it. The menu is really wonderful, so many very good choices. I had to go with Wood Fired Chicken Wings, and it was terrific. Their workers were all so sweet and attentive.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar.

8. Woody’s Grill & Tap

Enjoy fresh woodfired pizza with friends and family

All of the pizza is made in-house daily in a 500-degree wood fueled oven. Image courtesy of Woody’s Grill & Tap

58 Hemenway St | Boston |

Whether you want to catch up with friends or just organize a fun kickback with your family, Woody’s Grill & Tap is the perfect destination for your next outing! It’s most popular menu item is the pizza, which comes in small 10” and large 16” sizes. The small is perfect for people who want a pizza just for themselves. 

Dozens of toppings are available, such as buffalo chicken, pineapple, and spinach. You can add your own custom toppings to a cheese pizza or choose one of the many specialty pizzas on the menu. 

“We've found our new go-to pizza spot! We absolutely love the pizza here. There are so many great topping combinations that we've really enjoyed trying. Sometimes though, classic pepperoni can't be beat! We've been grabbing pizza to go for several weeks, and they are always fast and friendly when we arrive to pick it up.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Woody’s Grill & Tap.

9. Ducali Pizzeria & Bar

Neighborhood pizzeria in the North End with a charming outdoor patio

Photo of Ducali Pizzeria & Bar - Boston, MA, United States
Order a personal pizza or a large pizza to enjoy with friends. Image courtesy of Yelp.

289 Causeway St | North End |

Last, but certainly not least, on the list is Ducali Pizzeria & Bar. Located in the North End, Ducali Pizzeria features a charming outdoor patio perfect for enjoying warm summer nights in Boston. Many of the toppings are also locally-grown. You can order a small pie, which typically serves one person, or a large pie, which usually feeds two or three people. Enjoy!

“Who knew chicken, cheese & pesto could taste so good. The ingredients are so fresh, it reminds me of REAL Italian food, which I haven't found in American in a long time. Definitely recommend it if you're looking for food straight from Italy.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Ducali Pizzeria & Bar. 

Planning a social outing with friends and family? You can find a lot of hidden gems in Boston, including these top-rated pizzerias. Which ones on the list do you plan on visiting next? Let us know in the comment section below!


Related Articles

All Related Articles