Top 5 Sushi Restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana

The right sushi restaurant can make a dinner out as much about the experience as it is about the food. But with Indianapolis not exactly known for its Japanese cuisine, how do you know where to purchase a card from?

The following restaurants are a few of the top sushi destinations the city has to offer. When you opt for a virtual GiftYa card to one of these destinations, you can add a personalized note and send your card to your recipient in just seconds.

Looking for the perfect place to purchase a gift card to? Keep reading to learn the top 5 sushi restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana.

1. Sushi Boss

An innovative build-your-own sushi concept

803 W 10th St, Ste B, Indianapolis, IN 46202 sushiboss.com

Sushi Boss isn't your typical sushi restaurant. Instead, they offer an innovative experience that allows customers to build their very own sushi rolls. Pre-COVID, guests chose each ingredient they wanted inside their roll, and experience sushi masters carefully crafted their rolls right before their eyes. While you can still enjoy the full experience in the restaurant, Sushi Boss now also offers build-your-own kits that you can take home for a unique experience great for sharing with family and friends.

"I love this restaurant! I think the entire concept of building your own sushi is great. If you basically only like cream cheese and shrimp that's all you have to put in your roll. It's probably a great place to take a beginning sushi eater.

Prior to Covid we came here a few times for a quick sushi fix and always enjoyed it. During covid though is when I became a true fan and will continue to support this business because it's a true gem!!!!

To offset the decline in sales during Covid this business launched take home sushi kits where they sent you home with everything you needed to learn how to make sushi. BRILLIANT IDEA! We ordered three kits during lock down! It was so much fun experimenting and building our own sushi.

Support this business! They are doing everything thing they can to make lemonade out of the 2020 lemons we've all been getting." -Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Sushi Boss.

2. Blue Sushi Sake Grill

A modern sushi experience in a trendy, chic space

2721 E 86th St, Ste 100, Indianapolis, IN 46240 bluesushisakegrill.com

At Blue Sushi Sake Grill, the beautiful, chic modern restaurant space is rivaled only by their perfectly crafted sushi rolls. This upscale sushi restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Their extensive menu features every roll and sashimi you could ask for, alongside a wide variety of Japanese dishes, including lettuce wraps, miso soup, and more. This restaurant is far from a hidden secret, so you can expect a crowd, especially on weekends. If you want to avoid a wait, plan to make reservations ahead of time. The fun dining room makes this a great destination for date nights and special occasions alike!

"We have been doing take out but tonight we decided to dine in.  My son loves sushi so I decided to take advantage of the ALL DAY Happy Hour menu. The restaurant is beautifully decorated.  Service was great.  We did make advanced reservations to ensure we did not have to wait.  The food was absolutely delicious.  I tried the lychee low and it was yummy. My son and I absolutely enjoyed the specialty sashimi the most. Overall, everything was delicious and we will be back to try other dishes and drinks." -Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Blue Sushi Sake Grill.

3. Sushi House

A simple, unassuming restaurant serving up fresh, affordable rolls

11647 Fox Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46236 geistsushihouse.com

If you didn't know what you were looking for, it would be easy to drive by this unassuming restaurant. But what Sushi House lacks in extravagance, it makes up for in fresh ingredients, tasty dishes, and affordable prices. Perfect for grabbing carry-out or dining with your family, their rolls and sashimi will hit the spot without emptying out your wallet. They proudly claim to be the best sushi in Indianapolis, and many of their happy patrons would agree with that.

"First timer at Sushi House and was impressed!It had a nice, open atmosphere but the seating arrangements provided an intimate setting as well. The service was friendly, professional, and timely. They even give you complimentary candy with your check. That's always a plus ;) We ordered a few rolls (see photos) and each were delicious! My personal favorite that I've tried so far is probably the Geist Roll with the Sushi House Roll coming in at a close second. Their menu is fairly large with many different options to choose from. I can't wait to come back and try more! Sushi House, you've successfully won a returning customer." -Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Sushi House.

4. Kasai Sushi Bar & Kitchen

Decadent sushi favorites served up in a quirk restaurant

965 N Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219 www.kasaiindy.com

If you're looking for a fun night out, this quirky restaurant might be just the ticket. Serving up traditional sushi favorites in a space that blends the traditional with the quirky, a visit to Kasai Sushi Bar & Kitchen is as much about the experience as it is about the food. Party booths with screens and curtains make it easy to enjoy an intimate meal with friends or a date. Extravagant, perfectly plated dishes pack plenty of color and flavor. The menu features a wide selection of both sushi and Japanese cuisine, offering something for every taste.

"This place is one of those hole in the wall kind of restaurants where it looks maybe not great but has great food! When I walked into the restaurant I thought maybe I had found the wrong place. For some reason, the pictures on Yelp don't seem to match the interior of the restaurant. It has a lot of tables and a few booths. Apparently they offer hibachi but aren't doing it right now because of COVID.

My fiancé and I ordered the California roll, philly roll, kasai roll, and shrimp tempura roll. All the rolls had great flavor and were made well. They also had great presentation of food! I always like to order a California roll even though a lot of people don't consider it "real sushi." In my opinion, you can tell if a restaurant makes their rolls well by trying a California roll. If the roll is plain, their other rolls are likely to be basic with just okay flavor and taste. I really enjoyed the California roll here. I felt that it had good flavor. The kasai roll was a speciality roll named after the restaurant. My 5-star rating is based solely on the quality of food. If you're looking for a yummy sushi place on the east side of Indy, I would highly recommend trying this restaurant!" -Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Kasai Sushi Bar & Kitchen.

5. Sushi Club

Authentic Japanese restaurant serving up all-you-can-eat sushi

7230 W 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46214 sushiclubindy.com

With more than 81 items to choose from, Sushi Club has something for everyone. While you won't find a buffet line here, you can enjoy all-you-can-eat sushi in a traditional Japanese restaurant-style setting. Nosh on rolls, sashimi, and more, all made with the freshest ingredients and hand-rolled by a sushi master.

"My husband and I went here and it was amazing! It is this little while in the wall spot and so at first we were a little nervous, but the service was prompt and the food was amazing. We ordered the crab for the appetizer and two of their sushi rolls. It's been a few weeks since I have gone, but I still think about the food occasionally." -Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Sushi Club.

Whether you're looking for the perfect spot for an intimate date night or a fun location for an evening with friends, you can't go wrong with one of these top sushi restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana!