Top 10 Pizzerias in Mesa, Arizona That Locals Love

The city of Mesa is known for its friendly locals and gorgeous blue skies. But did you know that it also houses a wide selection of pizza parlors? There’s no shortage of great options to choose from in this vibrant city. Whether you are craving a slice of thin, New York style pizza or you want to share a large Chicago deep dish pie with your friends, you can easily do that in Mesa. Having trouble choosing a spot from the city’s wide selection of restaurants and pizzeria’s? We’re reviewing the top 10 pizzerias in Mesa in our latest article. 

Searching for the perfect present for your loved one? Surprise them with a virtual GiftYa card! Within seconds, you can send someone a virtual gift card to their favorite restaurant. GiftYa offers thousands of cards for different spots around Mesa, including the ones we featured below. Since the card is completely virtual, your loved one will never have to worry about losing it. Check out our full selection of cards now!

1. Nello’s Pizza Mesa

Laid back Italian restaurant known for its hearty deep dish pizza

2950 S Alma School Rd | Mesa | nellospizzamesa.com

Looking for a casual, family-friendly restaurant? Stop by Nello’s Pizza! For over 35 years, this locally-owned restaurant has delighted guests with its fresh and authentic pies. You can even spot the original owner, Brian Mei, walking around and greeting guests on any given night.

Now, onto the pizza. You can either build your own pizza or order a special off the menu. If you decide to build your own pie, you can customize the size, crust, cheese, and toppings! The Buffalo Chicken, Alaskan King, and Murphy pies are also popular among guests who want a Specialty Pizza.

“We had the deluxe combo and BBQ chicken pizzas on the gluten free crust and both were amazing. The homemade sausage on the deluxe combo was BOMB.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Nello’s Pizza Mesa. 

2. Venezia’s New York Style Pizzeria 

Pizzeria specializing in savory Italian food made from fresh ingredients

2721 S Ellsworth Rd, Suite 107 | Mesa | venezias.com

Located on Ellsworth Rd, Venezia’s New York Style Pizzeria is another top destination for hearty and authentic pizza pies. On the menu, you’ll find a wide selection of specialty pizzas, wings, pasta, and calzones! 

Small, large, x-large, and party size pizzas are all available. You can top your pizza off with savory foods like bacon, broccoli, chicken, and more. Dining with someone who is a vegetarian or vegan? No worries! Venezia’s offers plenty of vegan options. 

Fun fact: Venezia’s provided the pizza for the infamous pizza-on-the-roof-scene from season 3 of Breaking Bad. 

“As good as it gets for pizza and more...great beverages, beyond customer service, great location...Venezia's New York Style Pizza will not disappoint when you want a New York Style Pizza and more....this is a real gem.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Venezia’s New York Style Pizzeria.

3. Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante

Chicago style thin crust pizza made from decades-old family recipes

1947 N Lindsay Rd | Mesa | vitospizza.com

Since 1986, Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante has fed thousands of hungry families looking for some fresh and authentic Italian food. Vito’s has two locations in Arizona: Mesa and Gilbert. For this article, we’re reviewing the Mesa menu. 

At the Mesa location, you can build your own thin crust pizza or order one of the restaurant’s many specialty pies. If you decide to create your own pie, you can customize the size, crust, and toppings. Gluten-free and cauliflower crust are both available. 

“I absolutely LOVE Vito's thin crust pizza. I have only ordered pizza through takeout, and have yet to dine in or try any other entrees, but their pizza is absolutely delicious. I could almost eat an entire one by myself!! Yum!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante. 

4. Organ Stop Pizza

Spacious pizzeria that fills up with the sound of live music every night

Embed

1149 E Southern Ave | Mesa | organstoppizza.com

Who else has missed listening to live music? Luckily for you, you can get your fill at Organ Stop Pizza. Not only does this restaurant serve some of the best pizza in Mesa, but it also features a live organist! 

Guests can build their own 8-inch, 12-inch, or 14-inch pies using a variety of toppings such as sausage, bacon, pineapples, and onions. Several specialty pizzas are also available, including the Hawaiian, P.S.M., Spicy Italian, and Vegetarian. Whatever you pick, just try to save some room for dessert, as you won’t want to miss out on their premium hand-packed ice cream! 

“A fun, family-oriented pizza parlor featuring live music played on the largest Wurlitzer ever constructed. Basic pizza sizes and various toppings available. You may also choose from appetizers, salad bar, spaghetti dinners, Pepsi beverages, draft beer and wine. And ice cream for dessert. Enjoy it all while listening to the musical stylings of its various organists.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Organ Stop Pizza. 

5. Spinato’s Pizzeria

Pizza, calzones, pasta, and more Italian classics await you at this popular restaurant

96 S Rockford Dr, Suite 108 | Tempe | spinatospizzeria.com

In 1974, Spinato’s Pizzeria first opened its doors to the locals of Tempe, Arizona. Since then, guests from all around the area have traveled to Spinato’s for its fresh and authentic Italian cuisine. 

It should come as no surprise that their pizza is considered to be among the best in the city. Whether you order a hearty Get Meaty pie or a Spicy Italian pizza, you’ll quickly be filled and satisfied by the amazing flavors provided by these skillfully baked pies. 

“The FLAVOR! We got a thin crust and Sicilian with different toppings. They were both amazing. You could see sauce drizzle on top including all the spices. Seriously, a big trip to "flavor-town" (hahah! I had to do it).” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Spinato’s Pizzeria.

6. Pomo Pizzeria

Authentic Neapolitan pizza made from high-quality ingredients

366 N Gilbert Rd, Suite 106 | Gilbert | pomopizzeria.com

At Pomo Pizzeria, you can expect to be treated to some of the finest Italian food in Arizona. The methods used to make the restaurant’s famous dishes can be traced back several hundreds of years ago to southern Italy. 

As you enjoy a glass of wine or a cocktail, you’ll want to check out the restaurant’s popular pizza section. The pizzas are hand-tossed and oven-baked to produce a thin, crispy crust. Some of their most popular specialty pizzas include the Quattro Stagioni, Don Alfonso, and Diavola. Authentic pizza Romana, which is a thick, handmade focaccia-style pizza, is also served at this popular spot. 

“The Pomo pizza was perfect the crust was very thin, cooked they way it should be in a super hot oven. The toppings of sausage, onions, and peppers were deliciously glad we found this place.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Pomo Pizzeria. 

7. Casanova Brothers Pizza

New York style pizza served inside a friendly and laid back atmosphere

959 N Val Vista Dr | Gilbert | casanovabrospizza.com

If you’re someone who really loves pizza, you need to visit Casanova Brothers. Casanova Brothers Pizza brings a slice of old New York back home to Arizona. Inside the restaurant’s quaint and cozy walls, you’ll be able to relax and kick backkickback with your loved ones. 

Neapolitan, white, and Sicilan style pizzas are all served here! You can order them by the slice or as a whole pie. Don’t forget to add toppings! Fresh mozzarella, meatballs, bacon, and more savory toppings are available and ready to serve as the finishing touches on your pizza.

“If you are looking for traditional NY Pizza with a couple of old school owners, this is the place to go. Tony and his brother are the best! The pizza is delicious and it's never under cooked or burnt to a crisp. They treat you like family when you walk in through the door.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Casanova Brothers Pizza.

8. Mellow Mushroom

Family-friendly pizzeria serving up fresh, stone-baked pizzas

1665 S Stapley Dr | Mesa | mellowmushroom.com

You’ll find good vibes only at the chill Mellow Mushroom. Located on Stapley Dr, Mellow Mushroom offers a wide selection of savory stone-baked pizzas. From the Mighty Meaty to the Pacific Rim, the pizzas at Mellow Mushroom are of a higher order. But if none of the specialty pizzas entice you,  you can build your own! You can customize the size, cheese, and toppings for your pizza! 

Coming with someone who follows a specific diet? Vegan options are also available at the restaurant, such as the Vegan Tempeh Hoagie and Vegan Hummus. 

“The beers are large, cold and they have a great selection (many taps). Pizza here is top notch, the dough is something extraordinary, sauce is quality as are the plentiful toppings. Good wings too, I personally order them naked with sauce on the side for maximum crispiness.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Mellow Mushroom. 

9. Sourdough Pizza Italian Restaurant

Hidden gem in Mesa that serves some of the best pizza in the city

7440 E Main St | Mesa | sourdoughpizzarestaurant.com

Tired of going to the same chain restaurant for most of your dinner nights? Sourdough Pizza Italian Restaurant is a family-owned and operated shop located on E Main St. This small and cozy restaurant offers a welcoming and personable experience for all guests. 

All of the sourdough pizzas are handcrafted and baked to order using only the freshest ingredients. Whether you’re in the mood for a mini cheese pizza or you want to share an extra large pie with bell peppers and sausage, you can find the perfect meal to satisfy your appetite!

“I've been coming to Sourdough Pizza for many years, even before I started using Yelp. Bottom line- the pizza is excellent.  Always hot, tasty and perfect flavors.  It's a unique crust that is perfect with a crunch and still softness that really complements the savory tasty of the cheese and toppings.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Sourdough Pizza Italian Restaurant.