Italian Restaurants in Orlando That Serve the Best Dishes in the City

Italian food is always a great option when it comes to deciding what you want to have for dinner. In Orlando, there is no shortage of vibrant and authentic Italian restaurants to choose from. Whether you are in the mood for something fast and casual or you want to enjoy a special dining experience, Orlando offers a wide variety of restaurants suited to your preferences. In our latest article, we are reviewing some of the best restaurants the city has to offer!

Looking for the perfect present to give your friend or family member? Surprise them with a virtual GiftYa card! GiftYa cards can be applied to a number of restaurants in Orlando, including the ones we have featured in this article. Whether your friend is craving a slice of pizza or a hearty bowl of pasta, they can satisfy their taste buds at one of Orlando’s many Italian restaurants. 

1. Adriatico Trattoria Italiana

Classic Italian restaurant located in West Orlando

2417 Edgewater Dr. | West Orlando | adriatico-trattoria.com

Located in West Orlando, Adriatico Trattoria Italiana offers an elegant and high class dining experience for guests. If you’re looking for a restaurant that offers an intimate setting where you don’t have to shout over the noise of other patrons, you will love Adriatico. On the menu, you will find delicious and authentic dishes such as the Bruschetta Al Pomodoro, Caprese, and Fettuccine Alla Carbonara. An extensive wine menu is also available for you to enjoy alongside your meal.

“I got the Gnocchi dish with Gorgonzola sauce. I was worried at first it would be way too much cheese, but it wasn't! It was delicious. We topped off our meal by having tiramisu and a panna cotta which were both very tasty and I highly recommend both!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Adriatico Trattoria Italiana. 

2. Emeril’s Coastal Italian

Contemporary Italian restaurant serving delicious and authentic cuisine

453 Grand Blvd. | Miramar Beach | emerilsrestaurants.com

Known for its delicious seafood menu, Emeril’s Coastal Italian Restaurant is perfect for the everyday foodie. Whether you come for brunch or dinner, you are sure to find something to satisfy your tastebuds. Some of its most popular dishes include the Maine Lobster Roll, Oyster Spaghetti, and Seared Sea Scallops. Coleslaw, house fries, and smoked cheddar grits are also available to enjoy on the side. 

“Just finished Sunday brunch at Emeril's Coastal. We saw the man himself in the kitchen and told our waiter to ask Emeril to pick our appetizer and entrees. What a great decision!  They brought out the cast iron lobster with bread bread dipping that was scrumptious.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Emeril’s Coastal Italian. 

3. Siro Urban Italian Kitchen

Popular restaurant conveniently located inside the Orlando World Center Marriott Resort

8701 World Center Dr. | International Drive | marriott.com/hotel-restaurants

Siro Urban Italian Kitchen is known for its authentic and flavorful Italian cuisine. Many of its dishes are made from ingredients grown in the house garden or from local farmers. Because it is located inside the Marriott, many of its patrons are hotel guests. However, you don’t have to stay at the hotel in order to enjoy its fine cuisine. 

Classic Italian dishes including Margherita Pizza and Grilled Octopus are perfect for filling you up. If you’ve managed to save enough room for dessert, you can order sweet dishes like the Tiramisu or Cannoli. 

“This place is elegant and relaxing. Lots of choices on their menu with different types of pastas, pizza, and other interesting dishes. They also have varieties of brews and wine. Hubby and I ordered the Spicy Lobster  Carbonara to share since it's a huge portion enough for two.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Siro Urban Italian Kitchen. 

4. Napolitaly Italian Pizzeria

Laid back pizza joint perfect for a quick bite

3928 S Semoran Blvd. | Orlando | semoranpizza.com

Considered to be the destination of the best New York style pizza in the city, it’s no wonder Orlando natives consider Napolitaly Italian Pizzeria to be one of the best Italian restaurants around. For over 46 years, Napolitaly has cemented itself in the hearts and stomachs of local residents. On the menu, you’ll find hearty options including wings, garlic knots, and strombolis. You can either create your own pizza or order one of their signature pizzas. Delicious and creative options like the NY Style Steak & Cheese and Vegetable Alla Primavera are sure to fill you up!

“We ordered a large pepperoni & mushroom and it didn't disappoint!  It was SO good and I LOVE that it was canned mushrooms vs fresh mushrooms (a personal preference). A little oily bc of the pepperoni, but so delicious. I couldn't wait to call my picky pizza parents to tell them next time they're in town they have to try it!  I'll definitely be ordering from Napoli again!!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Napolitaly Italian Pizzeria. 

5. Bella Tuscany Ristorante

Family-owned restaurant known for its award-winning cuisine

13424 Summerport Village Pkwy. | West Orlando | bellatuscany.com

Known for its family-friendly atmosphere, Bella Tuscany Ristorante is perfect for casual nights out where you just want to enjoy some delicious food while relaxing with your loved ones. Located near Disney World and Universal Orlando, Bella Tuscany is the perfect destination after a long day of rides and entertainment. 

On the menu, you will find classic Italian options such as Linguine Carbonara, Gnocchi Bolognese, and Mushroom Raviolis. A lengthy wine list is also available. If the weather is nice enough, you can even choose to eat outside! 

“Whether you dine at the bar or the dining room you will experience some of the best gourmet Italian food I've had outside of NY. The chef cooks up daily specials and every one of his pasta dishes, seafood dishes, steaks, lamb, octopus, salads, etc, are without question the best food I've had anywhere in this neighborhood and greater Orlando.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Bella Tuscany Ristorante. 

6. Italian Garden Pizzeria

Contemporary Italian restaurant located in West Orlando

13770 W Colonial Dr. Suite 160 | West Orlando | italiangardenpizzeria.com

For years, Italian Garden Pizzeria has enjoyed a stellar reputation for its hearty and reasonably-priced dishes. Sicilian Thick Crust Pizzas, Personal Pan Pizzas, Stuffed Pizzas, and Specialty Pizzas are all available, making it easy to find a slice that you will love. Whether you are in the mood for Hawaiin Pizza or Chicken Club Pizza, you will find all of this and more on the menu. 

If you’re feeling hungry and need something to tide you over for the main course, you can select one of the restaurant’s many appetizers. Its most popular options include Fried Mozzarella Sticks, Garlic Bread, Bruschetta, and Tomato Caprice. Light soups and salads are also served! 

“Great food and great service. A fine family run restaurant where they are alway friendly and great is with a smile. Fresh salads, good pasta and fantastic New York style pizza!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Italian Garden Pizzeria. 

7. Pannullo’s Italian Restaurant

Popular Italian restaurant in Orlando featuring an outdoor patio space

216 S Park Ave. | Winter Park | order.pannullos.com

Located in Winter Park, Pannullo's Italian Restaurant is a prime destination for hearty, mouth watering Italian food. You can stop by the restaurant for either lunch or dinner. But no matter what time you go, you are sure to find a dish that leaves you feeling full and satisfied.

Some of its most popular dishes include the Bruschetta Caprese, Mussels, Lobster Ravioli, and Carbonara Fettuccine. Dinner salads such as the Ahi Tuna Fish Salad and Salmon Fish salad are also delicious crowd pleasers. 

“Great lunch this week on Pannullo's patio. In consideration of covid the servers were wearing masks and tables were spaced apart. The complimentary garlic infused olive oil and bread was a nice starter. The Greek salad was very fresh and the dressing on the salad was amazing!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Pannullo’s Italian Restaurant. 

There is no shortage of delicious and exciting Italian cuisine in Orlando. What are your favorite Italian dishes? Let us know in the comments! We love hearing from you.