Enjoy a Taste of Italy at the Top 9 Italian Restaurants in El Paso

Fill yourself up with some delicious and authentic Italian food in the gorgeous city of El Paso.

In the mood for some Italian food? El Paso is home to dozens of great Italian restaurants. But to make it easier to find the right one for you, we’ve compiled a list of the top-rated restaurants in the city. From laidback cafes to upscale eateries, we have a whole list of top spots that cater to a wide range of tastes. Check out our full guide to the best Italian restaurants in El Paso, Texas now!

Searching for the perfect gift for your loved one? Surprise them with a virtual GiftYa card! GiftYa offers hundreds of e-cards for restaurants, bars, stores, spas, and hotels around El Paso. You can even find e-cards for some of the restaurants featured below. Within seconds, you can send your loved one a GiftYa to their favorite restaurant along with a custom message. Once they receive it, they can link it to their debit card. It’s that easy! 

1. Trattoria Bella Sera

Gorgeous bi-level Italian café offering a small patio and hearty portions 

Photo of Trattoria Bella Sera - El Paso, TX, United States. Build your own pizza- Pepperoni and sausage
Build your own pizza with some friends! Image courtesy of Yelp.

3512 N Yarbrough Dr | El Paso | trattoriabellasera.com

Founded in 2007 by Venetian cook Guliana Leardini, Trattoria Bella Sera brings the spice and flavor of Italian cuisine right to your neighborhood. Many of the dishes trace their roots back to traditional Venetian cuisine. From the Capellini Al Pomodoro pasta to the Quattro Stagioni pizza, everything is made with skill and love. 

Guests have the option to build their own pasta or pizza. If you want to make your own pasta, you can choose the pasta shape, sauce, and veggies. Additional toppings like grilled chicken and shrimp are also available. To build your own pizza, you can add savory ingredients like artichokes and alfredo sauce to make it the way you like it. 

“I absolutely love this place. When you walk in the restaurant is set up to look like an open courtyard in Italy. It's very pretty. The service is always really good as is the food. Come hungry because their portions are surprisingly big and well priced.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Trattoria Bella Sera.

2. Cafe Italia

Local Italian restaurant that is known for its savory brick-oven pizzas

Photo of Cafe Italia - El Paso, TX, United States
Enjoy a glass of red wine with your pizza. Image courtesy of Yelp.

6705 N Mesa | El Paso | elpasocafeitalia.com

Cafe Italia is a locally-owned restaurant that focuses on providing delicious, unpretentious food in a warm environment. Most of the dishes are cooked in the cafe’s handmade wood-fired brick oven. They also make fresh mozzarella and fermented dough in-house daily. Cafe Italia is BYOB, so feel free to bring your favorite bottle of wine with you!

On the menu, you’ll find a variety of salads, pizzas, pastas, and calzones. Our favorite dishes include the Caprese salad and Linguine & Shrimp pasta. But don’t just take our word for it. You’ll have to come for yourself to see what all the hype is about. 

“In my opinion, Cafe Italia has the best pizza in El Paso. The pizza itself is fairly thin, but the crust itself is slightly thicker and so soft. The tomato sauce on their pizza is amazing. This time we chose to order the "All Meat" with salami, sausage, & pepperoni, and it was delicious.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Cafe Italia.

3. Mi Piaci Restaurant

Upscale Italian restaurant offering a lush, modern dining space

Photo of Mi Piaci Restaurant - El Paso, TX, United States
Treat yourself to a hearty bowl of pasta. You deserve it! Image courtesy of Yelp.

5411 N Mesa St, Suite 1 | El Paso | mipiaciep.com

At Mi Piaci, you can expect to be treated to some of the best Italian food in El Paso. This locally-owned restaurant is most known for its steak and seafood dishes. The steaks are certified 1855 Prime Black Angus Reserve while the seafood is flown in fresh from the Seattle Fish Company. 

Inside, you’ll find an elegant dining room overseen by welcoming and professional staff members. The menu is filled with savory dishes like the Penne Fra Diavolo and the Linguine alla Vodka. A full wine menu is also available. Enjoy! 

“Best Italian in El Paso! After moving from Houston I've missed all my favorite restaurants but luckily I found this place. It's just enough upscale without being pretentious and THE FOOD... WOW. The bruschetta for an appetizer is a must and from there you really can't go wrong with anything on the menu.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Mi Piaci Restaurant.

4. Monteleone’s

“Haunted” speakeasy restaurant that has served as a popular attraction for decades

Monteleone’s was featured on the SyFy channel due to its haunted reputation. Image courtesy of Trip Advisor.

3023 Gateway Blvd W | El Paso | facebook.com/Monteleones-Ristorante

Monteleone’s is the most unique spot on this list, mainly because it’s supposed to be haunted. The restaurant itself has only been operating for a couple of decades. However, the building that it’s housed in has been around for over 100 years. According to the owner, they’ve had numerous encounters with different spirits throughout their stay. When you go, make sure you snap a few photos of the restaurant’s fascinating artifacts!

Whether or not you believe in the paranormal, you’re still sure to have a great time at this popular Italian restaurant. Classic dishes like Chicken Parmigiana, Spaghetti, and more can be found on the menu. 

“Love this place! We stopped in on vacation really wanting some good Italian and we got it and some entertaining kitsch too! What a fun place to stop for a nice cooked-to-order chicken Parm or perfectly done lasagna. We'll be back.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Monteleone’s.

5. Buon Giorno Caffe

Friendly neighborhood cafe that offers all of the essentials

Buon Giorno Caffe is known for its fresh and savory dishes. Image courtesy of Yelp.

4727 Hondo Pass Ave | El Paso 

Looking for a new lunch spot? Check out Buon Giorno Caffe. This charming little cafe is known for its friendly service and healthy Italian meals. Buon Giorno Caffe is also a great option if you’re looking to support more local businesses. As a family-owned restaurant, Buon Giorno Caffe prides itself on offering fresh cuisine inside a welcoming atmosphere. 

The menu features an exciting array of salads, paninis, and desserts. Our favorite dishes include the Francesca Panini and House Salad. Hungry for dessert? We recommend treating yourself to a hot brownie topped with ice cream. Enjoy!

“Wonderful family-owned business atmosphere. Very clean restaurant and very polite service! A lot of healthy menu choices. Salads, soups, and sandwiches. Very good ingredients, hard to choose. I  just had the Enzo panini which was perfect. The salad had fresh greens and perfect dressing. Highly recommend this place for its charm and friendliness in addition to the great food!” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Buon Giorno Caffe.

6. Ardovino’s Pizza

Popular Italian restaurant that has been serving El Paso locals since 1961

206 Cincinnati Ave | El Paso | ardovinospizza.com

Who wants some pizza? You do! At Ardovino’s Pizza, you’ll find some of the finest pizza pies in all of El Paso. Since 1961, locals have flocked to Ardovino’s for its warm service and great deals. Lunch specials are offered Monday through Friday, so make sure you stop in during your next break at work! 

All pizzas are prepared with a mozzarella cheese base. Vegan cheese and gluten-free crust are also available upon request. You can either create your own pizza with four toppings or get one of their popular combination pizzas. In addition to pizza, Ardovino’s also serves salads, soups, and sandwiches. 

“Stopped in for dinner because I'd heard this was the best pizza place in El Paso. The ambiance is casual, but they also have secluded tables for a romantic date. First I had the Cranberry Bleu salad and it was excellent.  Their house balsamic was very good. Next, I had their Margherita pizza. Fantastic! Perfect crust; fresh mozzarella; excellent seasoning. Overall, an awesome dinner.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Ardovino’s Pizza.

7. Pasta Avanti

Charming Italian restaurant that is known for its laid back, intimate atmosphere

Who wants a plate of the Seafood Fettuccine Alfredo? Image courtesy of Yelp.

8001A N Mesa | El Paso 

When it comes to great Italian restaurants in El Paso, Pasta Avanti always delivers for its customers. Where do we even begin? Inside, you’ll find a charming and rustic atmosphere that is perfect for kicking back and relaxing with friends. The menu boasts a variety of hearty and authentic Italian dishes like Eggplant Parmigiana and Baked Rigatoni Jalapeno. 

Combos such as the Half-Chicken Parmigiana, Half-Baked Spaghetti combo are also great for people who don’t want to confine themselves to just one dish. Bringing the kids? Pasta Avanti also has a small kids menu featuring spaghetti, rigatoni, and spaghetti meatball.

“This is one great Italian restaurant. Virtually everything on the menu is unbeatable, even the salad is terrific. I had the eggplant Parmesan which was outstanding, but we also had the chicken piccata and the chicken marsala — unforgettable.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Pasta Avanti.

8. House of Taste

Locally-owned restaurant serving up warm hospitality and delicious food

Photo of House of Taste - El Paso, TX, United States. Sausage speghetti!
Try some Sausage Spaghetti. Image courtesy of Yelp.

4602 Tetons Dr | El Paso 

House of Taste is a cozy family restaurant that is perfect for people who prefer laidback, no-frills spots. Inside this rustic, little restaurant, you’ll be treated to great service and delicious Italian food. Salads, submarines, and spaghetti dishes are served along with burritos and tacos. 

While the combination of Italian and Mexican food might seem surprising at first, it is pulled off well at this fun and unique dining spot. Not only is the food delicious, but it is also offered at a low price. Some of our favorite dishes include the Meatball Sub and Pesto Salad. 

“Saw it off the road and it looked really friendly. A nice small family restaurant with the vibe to match. Got the Philly cheesesteak. This is the ONLY Philly cheesesteak in El Paso you will ever need. Don’t be turned off by the old look of the building. This place is worth the stop for lunch or dinner. Super in-expensive pizza.” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for House of Taste.

9. Como’s Italian Restaurant

Casual, laidback spot offering Italian staples including subs, pasta, and pizza

4030 N Mesa St | El Paso 

Last, but certainly not least, on our list is Como’s Italian Restaurant. If you’re looking for good food and service, Como’s is the way to go. Located on N Mesa St, Como’s offers a sophisticated, rustic atmosphere for guests. 

On the menu, you’ll find Italian classics like the Homemade Beef Ravioli and the Spaghetti Carbonara. Pizza is, of course, served and numerous savory toppings are available. Veal, seafood, and chicken dishes also make up a large part of the menu and are popular among guests. To finish off your meal, we recommend ordering a sweet dessert like the Chocolate Mousse or Tiramisu. You can thank us later!

“We absolutely loved the food and service here for our date night and are looking forward to coming back. We came a little later in the day, closer to close, but they still seated us and served us before the kitchen closed. The food was amazing and we all got to taste each other's food (so good!).” - Yelp Review

Purchase a GiftYa card for Como’s Italian Restaurant.

You don’t have to travel far to enjoy great Italian food in this city. El Paso offers a fine selection of Italian restaurants that vary in style and pricing, making it easy to find one that suits your unique taste and budget. Don’t feel like going out? You can also order in!

Which Italian restaurants do you plan to visit next? Let us know in the comment section below!

No items found.

Trae Bodge

Trae Bodge is the shopping expert here at GiftYa. Trae helps people find the best deals and ideas on popular new items to purchase.

Latest Posts